Monday, September 03, 2012

Community Medicine in Sanare


As I walk down the steep road to the clinic to work, I can see the lush hills on the horizon, the sun gleaming through the cloud forest.  I am in Sanare, a town of nearly 40,000 people  in the Venezuelan state of Lara (no, I’m not making this up. When people ask me why I came, I tell them it’s because my name is Lara.)  I have come to see Mission Barrio Adentro, the ambitious project to bring primary care to the population of Venezuela, in action. 

I have been assigned to work with Dr. David Chavez (no relation to Hugo), a Cuban physician who has come to Venezuela to offer medical services as part of the contract between Venezuela and Cuba, to provide free, accessible, medical care inside Venezuela’s underserved neighborhoods.  When Hugo Chavez was elected president of Venezuela in 1999, he sought to implement the principles of social medicine throughout the country of Venezuela. Articles 83-85 of the 1999 Venezuelan Constitution affirm the right to free and high quality healthcare for all Venezuelan citizens, through a system which is “decentralized and participative.”

In the years that followed, attempts to expand healthcare access to Venezuela’s underserved floundered, as the Venezuelan Medical Association resisted the idea of committing more resources to a public health sector which had been increasingly privatized. In addition, Venezuelan physicians were reluctant to live and practice in the barrios of the inner city.   In 2003, when an attempt by the pro-Chavez Mayor Freddy Bernal in the Libertador barrio of Caracas to draw in physicians to staff a series of local clinics failed, Bernal called upon the Cuban doctors who had offered emergency aid in the landslides of 1999. In April 2003, 58 Cuban doctors arrived in Caracas to start the program, providing primary care, but also conducting the first health survey which had ever been undertaken in the underserved barrio of Caracas.  The success and enthusiasm for this initial pilot project gave way to Mission Barrio Adentro in Fall 2003, the project to expand the public health system through the construction of a series of local clinics in the neighborhoods or barrios of Venezuela’s underserved. 

The clinic or consultorio, where we work is in the neighborhood of YacambĂș, and serves the surrounding families, about 2000 patients in all, staffed by a family physician and a nurse.  The building is simple, with 5 rooms, including an examination room, a procedure room, a storage space, a small classroom and waiting area.  Behind the clinic is the small house where the doctor lives. The waiting area is decorated with various health promotion posters, about dengue, the benefits of breastfeeding, preconceptional counseling among others. At the center of the room is a poster of the “Sala Situacional,” a report of health statistics in the neighborhood of 2000 patients served by the small clinic, including the number of residents, ages, a list of the most frequent diagnoses, and public health data, such as the number of homes with indoor plumbing, kitchens, etc.  

The morning is reserved for clinic visits; we start at 8AM.  Usually there are a couple of patients standing in front of the gate when I arrive, who have come from the nearby countryside, where there is no clinic. There are no appointments. Patients are seen in turn when they arrive.  Around 9AM, we take a break to give a short talk about dengue prevention for the 10 or so patients in the waiting room. Dr. David explains that there have already been a few cases of dengue fever in the area, but that the hemorrhagic form of the illness at times takes the lives of an otherwise healthy patient in a matter of hours.  He explains that it is critical to take measures to reduce the numbers of mosquitos which transmit the disease in the area.  

“In Cuba,” he states, “we have nearly eradicated dengue. We have brigadas (community health brigades) which go door to door, inspecting houses for receptacles of fresh water – buckets, plants, trash cans without lids – all possible breeding grounds for the Aedes Aegypti mosquito which is the vector for the dengue virus.” One of the patients in the waiting room raises his hand, “I’m part of the neighborhood association,” he says. “I could bring this up to the president and maybe we could have health brigades here.” 

From the beginning, participation has been a key component in the success of the Mission Barrio Adentro, which has expanded the number of annual patient visits through the Venezuelan public health service from 3.5 million in 1998 to 60 million annual visits on average from 2004 - 2010. By October 2009, there were nearly 7000 primary care clinics or consultorios in operation. For many residents in Venezuela’s barrios, Mission Barrio Adentro was the first way in which they were able to participate actively in the Bolivarian Revolution.  Each neighborhood of 1500 to 2000 residents which wanted a Cuban physician to serve them was expected to organize a health committee of 10 to 20 residents responsible for finding or constructing building to house the clinic, as well as finding sleeping quarters and food for the providers. 

As Dr. David walks me up the hill to have lunch, neighbors call out to him from nearby houses, “Cuba!” or “Doctor!” David responds, “Hermanazo!” (“Brother”) occasionally stopping to shake the hand of a passerby, give a child a high five, or to introduce me to the neighbors. 

Afternoons are for home visits, which are a critical piece of community medicine, David explains.  Community members offer us coffee or sweets, as we measure blood pressure, listen to the wheezy lungs of a child, or write the occasional prescription.  The family doctor must perform an annual survey of the patient’s in the community, filling out the “family chart,” in addition to the individual patient chart. In the family chart are listed all of the family members, as well as an assessment of their living conditions, illnesses, medications, social circumstances. Medical students, community health workers or the nurse assist with this task.  

Statistics are a critical component to the work of the family doctor. In Cuba, David explains, teams of statisticians work with doctors and nurses to compile health data. However, in Venezuela, the CDI (Integrated Diagnostic Center) which serves the patients of the various consultorios of Sanare, with a broad range of services, such as imaging, laboratory services, dentistry, ophthalmology and optometry, to name a few, only has two statisticians. A typical CDI in Cuba would have an entire team of statisticians, and so David spends his Saturday mornings compiling the health statistics for the week, the number of visits, patient ages and diagnoses.  A health report is compiled annually to help physicians direct preventive health efforts appropriately.

As I watch David tabulate numbers of patients on the back of a sheet of scrap paper, my eyes glaze over.  We have just worked the overnight shift in the CDI, where there is an office which operates as a small emergency room/urgent care in a community hospital. Although we slept most of the night as few patients come in after 11PM, I am still tired.  I shake my head to wake myself up a bit and check my watch. It is 10:30AM and the clinic is open until noon on Saturday. I think to myself that I’m probably violating duty hours… 

“It’s a lot of work to be a family doctor,” I say. “It is,” says David with a smile. “My patients know I’m always at home. They know they can knock at any time. It’s a lifelong commitment to be a community physician.”

He sends me home shortly thereafter, as no patients have arrived since 9AM.  As I walk up the hill back home, I think about the remarkable sacrifice Dr. David and his coworkers are making, spending between one to three years at a time on missions in distant locations, far from their loved ones.  Yet this vibrant gentleman with white hair and boundless energy makes this work appear cheerful and effortless.   

Much more to come, I promise, as there are many things to tell.  I must credit Steve Brouwer, author of Revolutionary Doctors: How Venezuela and Cuba are Changing the World’s Conception of Health Care, as much of the statistics in this blog post and certainly in future ones are coming from the book which inspired me to make this visit.

2 comments:

roona said...

yay sounds fun! pictures? please? i wanna go with you :)

lakele said...

envidiable!!! Muchas gracias Lara