Thursday, September 13, 2012

Medical Education: Training the Next Generation of Venezuelan Doctors



“Al venir a la tierra, todo hombre tiene derecho a que se eduque, y después en pago, el deber de contribuir a la educación de los demás.” – José Martí Pérez

“On arrival to earth, every man has the right to an education, and afterwards in return, the duty to contribute to the education of others.”

Every clinic affiliated with Mision Barrio Adentro features the photo of five individuals: Simon Bolivar, Che Guevara, Fidel Castro, Hugo Chavez, and José Martí Pérez, the 19th century Cuban intellectual who dedicated his life to the liberation of Cuba.  His words infuse the daily work of the Cuban doctors and the generations of Venezuelan students who train alongside them.  The above quote introduced the presentation of a group of sixth-year medical students during their preliminary defense of their thesis for graduation of medical school. All students enrolled in MIC, the program for training in Integrative Community Medicine through Mision Barrio Adentro, must complete a thesis, which is a community health intervention designed by groups of four students regarding a public health issue which affects their community.  This group of students chose the topic of sexually transmitted infections, a taboo subject in this small Catholic community, and taught a group of over 100 adolescents in a series of 10 workshops about sexually transmitted infections which included discussions about prevention of disease, contraception, and role plays for negotiating safe sex.  One of the workshops was for the parents of these adolescents, to answer questions and encourage open conversations among family members about sexually transmitted infections.  Their conclusions: Adolescents have limited knowledge about sexually transmitted infections, and few of them receive this information from doctors. The health system has great potential to impact this population with further activities of this sort and enhance healthy behavior. The presentation and the project of this group of medical students was extremely well executed and would have stood among the best Community-Oriented Primary Care Projects, which are a graduation requirement for family medicine residents in the United States.

In the fall of 2003, when Cuban medical graduates started arriving in Venezuela for residency training in family and community medicine, many Venezuelan students started to come forward, asking to train alongside the Cuban doctors as well.  As early as 2004, some Venezuelan medical graduates joined the Cuban medical residents for training in family and community medicine, while working in Mision Barrio Adentro.  They would later by joined by several hundreds of their compatriots, who would graduate from the Latin American Medical School of Cuba between 2005 to 2008. However, these would not be enough primary care doctors to serve the entire country.  Chavez aims to train at least 30,000. Knowing that the Barrio Adentro project would not be sustainable without some way to train Venezuelan doctors, in 2003, a national commission was established to develop and oversee the National Training Program in Comprehensive Community Medicine, which brought together Cuban medical educators, members of the Venezuelan health ministry and six Venezuelan universities.  Mision Sucre, the program of the Venezuelan government designed to bring university level education directly to the working-class citizens of small towns and barrios, became the vehicle to recruit students to train with Barrio Adentro.  Since its inception, MIC has trained thousands of medical students, graduating its first class of nearly 7000 students in 2011, with about 24,000 others currently enrolled, as compared with 22,000 students enrolled in the traditional Venezuelan medical system.

In Venezuela, medical education is six years long, as in most of the world, where medical education starts immediately after secondary school, rather different from our system in the USA where everyone has to complete a bachelor’s degree prior to entering medical school. In the traditional Venezuelan medical system, people explain, students spend 5 years in the classroom, and only spend the final year seeing patients in the hospital.  This fact has been mentioned to me by many different students studying in the Barrio Adentro system, and I find it astonishing and unusual, for in other countries where I have been such as Lebanon and Brazil, students spend the first two years in classes and the final four years seeing patients. It is difficult to imagine how one could learn medicine without examining patients; to reflect personally, for me it was really only after four years of seeing patients, at the end of my second year of family medicine residency, when I really started to feel like I could direct my questions and physical exam to a particular diagnosis and plan with efficiency and rigor.  As all my professors will say, patients don`t always read the textbooks.

With this in mind, the system of medical education established as part of Barrio Adentro, initiates student contact with patients from day one. In the clinic where I am working with Dr. David, there are two premedical students who started only a month ago, one second year medical student, and two sixth-year students.  The sixth-years see patients alone at times, and can ask questions of the doctor when they have doubts. The second-year hasn’t learned to take a clinical history yet, but she and the first-years come to the clinic every morning and are involved in other activities, weighing and measuring patients, visiting families door-to-door, and helping with public health projects, putting together the family charts, helping to organize health information. 

One morning, after the early rush of patients had subsided, I sat in the back with the students and chatted.  “If it weren’t for Barrio Adentro,” I ask, “would you have been able to go to medical school?” All four students, from the pre-meds to the sixth-years, shake their heads.  Yohnny Gonzalez, one of the pre-medical students elaborates. “First of all, the medical school is in Barquisimeto (the big city an hour away), then there are the books, which are really expensive, and there’s transportation costs, and you have to rent an apartment in the city. There’s no way.”  Indeed, some of the students travel a ways from their family’s homes to take classes in the small town of Sanare.  They all receive a scholarship from the government for books and transportation. When I ask the group of eight women in the fourth-year class this question, the answer is the same.  Most of the students in the fourth-year class in Sanare have children, and almost all of them are single mothers. 

The decision to offer this critical education in the place where it is most needed serves a number of important purposes. The first is access, as the students testify.  Secondly, being from the community, the students know the needs and local culture better than anyone else, making this intervention quite different from the way in which many countries attempt to solve the problem of healthcare access, by requiring doctors to work for a short period in an underserved area after graduation from medical school. Venezuela also has this requirement; all medical graduates trained in Barrio Adentro or the traditional schools are placed in an underserved  area for one year after completing medical school before going on to train in a residency program.  However, this brings me to the third and perhaps most important purpose: sustainability and beating the brain drain.  How many medical students have I met in other countries, who had no intention of staying in their home country after completing their medical training?  The students in the traditional Venezuelan system are no different.  Certainly there are exceptions of medical graduates whom I have already mentioned who joined Mision Barrio Adentro, however, the vast majority intend to graduate and remain in Venezuela’s large cities, to work in lucrative specialties, treating the wealthy.

Let me be fair, as it is easy to demonize the wealthy specialists who drive around in cars with tinted windows, collecting the payments of patients shuffled quickly through the clinic before heading off to a golf match.  I’m as tree-hugging, immigrant-loving as the next pinko-feminist, but I grew up in a big city and couldn’t imagine settling down in a small town, so I’m not about to promise to dedicate my whole life to being a rural community doctor.  When you speak with community doctors in the US, at times they will tell you they feel isolated from their colleagues, out of touch with medical education.  I imagine that for a doctor at the community level who does not find the Barrio Adentro program a threat to their pocketbook,  the program has a lot of promise, possibly to standardize the quality of care and perhaps even the quality of life of the physicians, at the very least, those interested in teaching.  It is no small task to attempt to implement medical education and primary care on such a broad level, and one must be wary of quality control with this immense undertaking.  No doubt, some of the students will choose to go on to study in other countries, or to live and practice in Venezuela’s big cities.  However, many of them state that they intend to stay in their villages of origin, excited to participate in this revolution of medical education and to take advantage of an opportunity that they otherwise may never have had.

No comments: