“The rich...are led by an invisible hand to make nearly the same distribution of the necessaries of life, which would have been made, had the earth been divided into equal portions among all its inhabitants, and thus without intending it, without knowing it, advance the interest of the society..." Adam Smith, 1759
Two people walk by my table, from the Comité de Calidad y Valores (the Value and Quality Committee) come to my table. “What is this?” they ask. I explain that it is a passionfruit cheesecake. “Hmm, looks delicious. How about 5 sanareños per slice?”
I am at the trueque, the market which is being held in Sanare, organized more or less once a month. But the difference about this market is that no money changes hands here. Instead, in keeping with the ancient Andean tradition of barter, people exchange goods or services. Or sometimes, they use Sanareños, the currency of the local market, which have no monetary value, but aid in the process of the exchange.
The trueque is a movement, which was revitalized in Latin America, most recently in the 1990s in Argentina. As the rapid rate of inflation caused prices to skyrocket through the 1980s and 1990s, and the unemployment rate tripled, people sought a means of trade outside of the traditional economic system, which would value the labor of those who were excluded from the mainstream capitalist market. In 1995, Carlos da Sanza, Ruben Ravera and Horacio Covas organized a barter market in the Bernal province of Argentina, and the Red Global de la Trueque (RGT), the Global Network of Barter, was born.
Over the years, these movements have risen and fallen in Argentina, spreading organically and collaborating with similar movements in other countries. In 2005, in his television program, Aló Presidente, Chávez discussed the notion of developing local community currencies, and a month later, the currency the TXAI was issued for exchange at the 6th World Social Forum in Venezuela. The following year the president contracted Ravera and Covas, co-founders of the RGT of Argentina, as well as two coordinators of the Sistema de Trueke de Santa Elena en Medellín (Colombia) to build a network of barter markets in Venezuela.
A requirement for participation in the barter market is attendance at a workshop explaining how the system works. Two days before I stayed up late to make my cheesecake, Mario, a friend of Omar Sierra, the Venezuela Consul in Boston, invited me to such a workshop. Mario is a sociologist and sculptor, who studied for a number of years in the US, and during my final week in Sanare he introduced me to some of the various cultural and political activities taking place in the small town.
Pablo Mayayo, one of the coordinators of the Sistema de Trueke de Santa Elena who has been commissioned by the Venezuelan government to promote the treuque, delivers the workshop in the shaded patio of the Fondacion de Café in Sanare. It is attended by some 20 people. Mayayo, as people call him, is a dynamic speaker, with long hair and a beard, who travels around Venezuela giving similar workshops. He intersperses his explanation of the logistics of the barter market with some theory and history. “This is an area of coffee production,” he explains. “But you can’t eat coffee.”
Mayayo goes on to describe a story that the workshop participants know too well. “The coffee harvest is in October…but by December, the money’s all gone. And then what do you do for the rest of the year?” He refers to the precarious position of the small farmer within the global economy, which in many ways hasn’t changed since colonialism: farmers in the global south producing one product only, to sell to middle-men at whatever price they ask, who then hike up the prices and sell to a third party in the global north. Sure, I buy fair-trade coffee. Perhaps the farmers get a few more cents for their labor, but it doesn’t solve the problem. I think back to Escalera, where I worked with Dr. Hilario for a few days. Bananas, corn or potatoes grew alongside the coffee plants, and even some cows or goats grazed by the side of the road, but the man who drove us back to town, a three-hour drive around the landslide which shut down the main road, was going to buy basic necessities such as milk, flour, sugar and salt. You can’t eat coffee.
Pablo explains that the trueque allows participants to give products a more appropriate value than in the capitalist market. At the beginning of the market, producers and members of the committee of value and quality agree on a price for the goods; then in the general assembly if there is a concern, for example, if the price of bread is too high, people can raise their hands and complain. Not only products are sold in the trueque, but services and skills. “Everyone knows something,” says Mayayo, “whether it’s saving seeds for next year’s harvest, or how to make a cake, everyone has something to teach and something to learn.”
When the workshop is over, Mario explains to me that he sees the trueque at this point as more of a social experiment than an economic one, but it is gaining popularity. “It’s as much about the joy of the trueque, to give something to someone and receive something in return.” He explains that in the market, he can sell his sculptures for 1000 bolivares (over $200), but he would happily exchange a sculpture for a particularly rare balm for the joints, which he uses to massage his sore wrists and shoulders after a long day of woodcarving.
At the trueque we trade in the local currency, Sanareños, which have no monetary value. They are produced for the purpose of exchange, and after participating in three barter markets, participants receive 100 Sanareños to further promote the exchange; he passes around the small square bills for demonstration. The idea is to encourage exchange rather than accumulation of wealth. The idea makes sense, particularly in light of the most recent collapse of the US housing market and the bailout of the banks. Some economists such as James Galbraith critiqued Obama’s so-called economic stimulus package, arguing if you bailout the rich, they will save money in times of economic strain, but if you bail out the working class, they will have no other option but to put most of the money back into circulation, thereby truly stimulating the economy.
On Friday morning, I arrive at the trueque, which is held in a large gymnasium in the center of town, with a passionfruit cheesecake, and a frilly, black shirt to exchange. I fill out a form listing my products and wait for the members of the Value and Quality Committee to stop at my table and suggest a price for the cake. 5 sanareños a slice, 20 for the shirt. Not bad, considering that a half-liter of cocuy, the local moonshine which is made from cactus and tastes rather like mezcal, goes for 20 sanareños.
Others filter slowly into the gymnasium, arranging their products on various tables, the prices marked with pieces of masking tape. Sharing the table with me is a woman with a range of seedlings in black plastic bags and plastic bags of goat manure. To my left, a woman with small bags of oregano and other herbs, bottles of cocuy, and small bars of goat fat, which people use as a moisturizer and to help scars to heal. At a table in the center are the truequeritos, a group of children about 6-12 years old, wearing matching shirts and blue baseball caps, spooning quesillo, Venezuelan flan, into cups. Next to them sits an artesan, who arranges his leather wallets, keychains and other small trinkets on the table. Others sit before tables of fresh vegetables, organized in colorful piles, used clothing, baked goods. There is even someone selling bags of chemical fertilizer.
There are about 50 participants in all, a small number in comparison to the 80-100 or so participants who normally join in, but now everyone is busy preparing for the upcoming presidential elections. After a short convocation, the trueque begins. Participants bustle back to their tables. Children run across the stadium, munching on pieces of cake. “Is this seedling a yucca?” asks a 7-year-old boy. He hands the woman a piece of pumpkin in exchange and runs the seedling back to his mother. Others exchange the paper bills, which come in denominations of 1, 5, 10, 20. The excitement is palpable. I sit back impatiently, waiting for someone to ask about my cake. A woman offers me two giant pincushions made out of soda bottles decorated with confetti in exchange for my shirt. I wrinkle up my nose and say they won’t fit in my suitcase. Finally, I sell the shirt and a slice of cake. I hurry across the gymnasium to buy a charming little jumpsuit for my baby cousin. 25 sanareños, but impossibly hip. I hurry back to my table, and the women next to me say, people stopped by for cake, but you weren’t here.
“Geranium tea?” says Rebecca, carrying a thermos and a stack of tiny cups. “Sure,” I say, handing over a 5 sanareño bill. She gives me four in return. Among her stack of bills are some larger squares, which look different. “This is from a different state,” she explains, “We can go there and join in the treuque, too.” She then explains that she owns a posada, like a bed and breakfast, in Sanare. “When I want to go to the beach, I can go stay in a posada and pay with these, and when people from the posada by the beach want to stay in the mountains, they come stay here. The sanareños aren’t worth money,” she says. “They’re just a tool.”
A useful tool at that, and a far cry from the TXAI issued for the World Social Forum in 2006, which, according to The Economist, “could not buy anything really necessary, like mineral water.” By the time I had accumulated any Sanareños, all the cocuy was gone, but I did have a few lovely little trinkets, some key chains, and had sipped some delicious tea.
I take a seat next to Mario, at the closing assembly of the trueque, where discuss the positives, and suggestions for improvements for next time. I give Mario a taste of the remains of my cake, and he says, “I’d like to make a trade.” From his bag, he pulls a beautiful owl, which he sculpted from a candle. I shake my head in astonishment. “No way,” I protest. “It’s not a fair trade.” But he insists, “It’s not just about exchanging. What did I tell you before? It’s the joy of trueque, to give and receive in return.”
Two people walk by my table, from the Comité de Calidad y Valores (the Value and Quality Committee) come to my table. “What is this?” they ask. I explain that it is a passionfruit cheesecake. “Hmm, looks delicious. How about 5 sanareños per slice?”
I am at the trueque, the market which is being held in Sanare, organized more or less once a month. But the difference about this market is that no money changes hands here. Instead, in keeping with the ancient Andean tradition of barter, people exchange goods or services. Or sometimes, they use Sanareños, the currency of the local market, which have no monetary value, but aid in the process of the exchange.
The trueque is a movement, which was revitalized in Latin America, most recently in the 1990s in Argentina. As the rapid rate of inflation caused prices to skyrocket through the 1980s and 1990s, and the unemployment rate tripled, people sought a means of trade outside of the traditional economic system, which would value the labor of those who were excluded from the mainstream capitalist market. In 1995, Carlos da Sanza, Ruben Ravera and Horacio Covas organized a barter market in the Bernal province of Argentina, and the Red Global de la Trueque (RGT), the Global Network of Barter, was born.
Over the years, these movements have risen and fallen in Argentina, spreading organically and collaborating with similar movements in other countries. In 2005, in his television program, Aló Presidente, Chávez discussed the notion of developing local community currencies, and a month later, the currency the TXAI was issued for exchange at the 6th World Social Forum in Venezuela. The following year the president contracted Ravera and Covas, co-founders of the RGT of Argentina, as well as two coordinators of the Sistema de Trueke de Santa Elena en Medellín (Colombia) to build a network of barter markets in Venezuela.
A requirement for participation in the barter market is attendance at a workshop explaining how the system works. Two days before I stayed up late to make my cheesecake, Mario, a friend of Omar Sierra, the Venezuela Consul in Boston, invited me to such a workshop. Mario is a sociologist and sculptor, who studied for a number of years in the US, and during my final week in Sanare he introduced me to some of the various cultural and political activities taking place in the small town.
Pablo Mayayo, one of the coordinators of the Sistema de Trueke de Santa Elena who has been commissioned by the Venezuelan government to promote the treuque, delivers the workshop in the shaded patio of the Fondacion de Café in Sanare. It is attended by some 20 people. Mayayo, as people call him, is a dynamic speaker, with long hair and a beard, who travels around Venezuela giving similar workshops. He intersperses his explanation of the logistics of the barter market with some theory and history. “This is an area of coffee production,” he explains. “But you can’t eat coffee.”
Mayayo goes on to describe a story that the workshop participants know too well. “The coffee harvest is in October…but by December, the money’s all gone. And then what do you do for the rest of the year?” He refers to the precarious position of the small farmer within the global economy, which in many ways hasn’t changed since colonialism: farmers in the global south producing one product only, to sell to middle-men at whatever price they ask, who then hike up the prices and sell to a third party in the global north. Sure, I buy fair-trade coffee. Perhaps the farmers get a few more cents for their labor, but it doesn’t solve the problem. I think back to Escalera, where I worked with Dr. Hilario for a few days. Bananas, corn or potatoes grew alongside the coffee plants, and even some cows or goats grazed by the side of the road, but the man who drove us back to town, a three-hour drive around the landslide which shut down the main road, was going to buy basic necessities such as milk, flour, sugar and salt. You can’t eat coffee.
Pablo explains that the trueque allows participants to give products a more appropriate value than in the capitalist market. At the beginning of the market, producers and members of the committee of value and quality agree on a price for the goods; then in the general assembly if there is a concern, for example, if the price of bread is too high, people can raise their hands and complain. Not only products are sold in the trueque, but services and skills. “Everyone knows something,” says Mayayo, “whether it’s saving seeds for next year’s harvest, or how to make a cake, everyone has something to teach and something to learn.”
When the workshop is over, Mario explains to me that he sees the trueque at this point as more of a social experiment than an economic one, but it is gaining popularity. “It’s as much about the joy of the trueque, to give something to someone and receive something in return.” He explains that in the market, he can sell his sculptures for 1000 bolivares (over $200), but he would happily exchange a sculpture for a particularly rare balm for the joints, which he uses to massage his sore wrists and shoulders after a long day of woodcarving.
At the trueque we trade in the local currency, Sanareños, which have no monetary value. They are produced for the purpose of exchange, and after participating in three barter markets, participants receive 100 Sanareños to further promote the exchange; he passes around the small square bills for demonstration. The idea is to encourage exchange rather than accumulation of wealth. The idea makes sense, particularly in light of the most recent collapse of the US housing market and the bailout of the banks. Some economists such as James Galbraith critiqued Obama’s so-called economic stimulus package, arguing if you bailout the rich, they will save money in times of economic strain, but if you bail out the working class, they will have no other option but to put most of the money back into circulation, thereby truly stimulating the economy.
On Friday morning, I arrive at the trueque, which is held in a large gymnasium in the center of town, with a passionfruit cheesecake, and a frilly, black shirt to exchange. I fill out a form listing my products and wait for the members of the Value and Quality Committee to stop at my table and suggest a price for the cake. 5 sanareños a slice, 20 for the shirt. Not bad, considering that a half-liter of cocuy, the local moonshine which is made from cactus and tastes rather like mezcal, goes for 20 sanareños.
Others filter slowly into the gymnasium, arranging their products on various tables, the prices marked with pieces of masking tape. Sharing the table with me is a woman with a range of seedlings in black plastic bags and plastic bags of goat manure. To my left, a woman with small bags of oregano and other herbs, bottles of cocuy, and small bars of goat fat, which people use as a moisturizer and to help scars to heal. At a table in the center are the truequeritos, a group of children about 6-12 years old, wearing matching shirts and blue baseball caps, spooning quesillo, Venezuelan flan, into cups. Next to them sits an artesan, who arranges his leather wallets, keychains and other small trinkets on the table. Others sit before tables of fresh vegetables, organized in colorful piles, used clothing, baked goods. There is even someone selling bags of chemical fertilizer.
There are about 50 participants in all, a small number in comparison to the 80-100 or so participants who normally join in, but now everyone is busy preparing for the upcoming presidential elections. After a short convocation, the trueque begins. Participants bustle back to their tables. Children run across the stadium, munching on pieces of cake. “Is this seedling a yucca?” asks a 7-year-old boy. He hands the woman a piece of pumpkin in exchange and runs the seedling back to his mother. Others exchange the paper bills, which come in denominations of 1, 5, 10, 20. The excitement is palpable. I sit back impatiently, waiting for someone to ask about my cake. A woman offers me two giant pincushions made out of soda bottles decorated with confetti in exchange for my shirt. I wrinkle up my nose and say they won’t fit in my suitcase. Finally, I sell the shirt and a slice of cake. I hurry across the gymnasium to buy a charming little jumpsuit for my baby cousin. 25 sanareños, but impossibly hip. I hurry back to my table, and the women next to me say, people stopped by for cake, but you weren’t here.
“Geranium tea?” says Rebecca, carrying a thermos and a stack of tiny cups. “Sure,” I say, handing over a 5 sanareño bill. She gives me four in return. Among her stack of bills are some larger squares, which look different. “This is from a different state,” she explains, “We can go there and join in the treuque, too.” She then explains that she owns a posada, like a bed and breakfast, in Sanare. “When I want to go to the beach, I can go stay in a posada and pay with these, and when people from the posada by the beach want to stay in the mountains, they come stay here. The sanareños aren’t worth money,” she says. “They’re just a tool.”
A useful tool at that, and a far cry from the TXAI issued for the World Social Forum in 2006, which, according to The Economist, “could not buy anything really necessary, like mineral water.” By the time I had accumulated any Sanareños, all the cocuy was gone, but I did have a few lovely little trinkets, some key chains, and had sipped some delicious tea.
I take a seat next to Mario, at the closing assembly of the trueque, where discuss the positives, and suggestions for improvements for next time. I give Mario a taste of the remains of my cake, and he says, “I’d like to make a trade.” From his bag, he pulls a beautiful owl, which he sculpted from a candle. I shake my head in astonishment. “No way,” I protest. “It’s not a fair trade.” But he insists, “It’s not just about exchanging. What did I tell you before? It’s the joy of trueque, to give and receive in return.”
No comments:
Post a Comment