Tuesday, September 18, 2012

Trueque - the ancient tradition of barter - alive and well

“The rich...are led by an invisible hand to make nearly the same distribution of the necessaries of life, which would have been made, had the earth been divided into equal portions among all its inhabitants, and thus without intending it, without knowing it, advance the interest of the society..."  Adam Smith, 1759

Two people walk by my table, from the Comité de Calidad y Valores (the Value and Quality Committee) come to my table.  “What is this?” they ask.  I explain that it is a passionfruit cheesecake.  “Hmm, looks delicious. How about 5 sanareños per slice?”

I am at the trueque, the market which is being held in Sanare, organized more or less once a month.  But the difference about this market is that no money changes hands here.  Instead, in keeping with the ancient Andean tradition of barter, people exchange goods or services.  Or sometimes, they use Sanareños, the currency of the local market, which have no monetary value, but aid in the process of the exchange.

The trueque is a movement, which was revitalized in Latin America, most recently in the 1990s in Argentina.  As the rapid rate of inflation caused prices to skyrocket through the 1980s and 1990s, and the unemployment rate tripled, people sought a means of trade outside of the traditional economic system, which would value the labor of those who were excluded from the mainstream capitalist market. In 1995, Carlos da Sanza, Ruben Ravera and Horacio Covas organized a barter market in the Bernal province of Argentina, and the Red Global de la Trueque (RGT), the Global Network of Barter, was born.

Over the years, these movements have risen and fallen in Argentina, spreading organically and collaborating with similar movements in other countries. In 2005, in his television program, Aló Presidente, Chávez discussed the notion of developing local community currencies, and a month later, the currency the TXAI was issued for exchange at the 6th World Social Forum in Venezuela. The following year the president contracted Ravera and Covas, co-founders of the RGT of Argentina, as well as two coordinators of the Sistema de Trueke de Santa Elena en Medellín (Colombia) to build a network of barter markets in Venezuela.

A requirement for participation in the barter market is attendance at a workshop explaining how the system works.  Two days before I stayed up late to make my cheesecake, Mario, a friend of Omar Sierra, the Venezuela Consul in Boston, invited me to such a workshop. Mario is a sociologist and sculptor, who studied for a number of years in the US, and during my final week in Sanare he introduced me to some of the various cultural and political activities taking place in the small town.

Pablo Mayayo, one of the coordinators of the Sistema de Trueke de Santa Elena who has been commissioned by the Venezuelan government to promote the treuque, delivers the workshop in the shaded patio of the Fondacion de Café in Sanare. It is attended by some 20 people.  Mayayo, as people call him, is a dynamic speaker, with long hair and a beard, who travels around Venezuela giving similar workshops. He intersperses his explanation of the logistics of the barter market with some theory and history.   “This is an area of coffee production,” he explains. “But you can’t eat coffee.”

Mayayo goes on to describe a story that the workshop participants know too well. “The coffee harvest is in October…but by December, the money’s all gone. And then what do you do for the rest of the year?” He refers to the precarious position of the small farmer within the global economy, which in many ways hasn’t changed since colonialism: farmers in the global south producing one product only, to sell to middle-men at whatever price they ask, who then hike up the prices and sell to a third party in the global north. Sure, I buy fair-trade coffee. Perhaps the farmers get a few more cents for their labor, but it doesn’t solve the problem.  I think back to Escalera, where I worked with Dr. Hilario for a few days.  Bananas, corn or potatoes grew alongside the coffee plants, and even some cows or goats grazed by the side of the road, but the man who drove us back to town, a three-hour drive around the landslide which shut down the main road, was going to buy basic necessities such as milk, flour, sugar and salt.  You can’t eat coffee.

Pablo explains that the trueque allows participants to give products a more appropriate value than in the capitalist market.  At the beginning of the market, producers and members of the committee of value and quality agree on a price for the goods; then in the general assembly if there is a concern, for example, if the price of bread is too high, people can raise their hands and complain. Not only products are sold in the trueque, but services and skills. “Everyone knows something,” says Mayayo, “whether it’s saving seeds for next year’s harvest, or how to make a cake, everyone has something to teach and something to learn.”

When the workshop is over, Mario explains to me that he sees the trueque at this point as more of a social experiment than an economic one, but it is gaining popularity.  “It’s as much about the joy of the trueque, to give something to someone and receive something in return.”  He explains that in the market, he can sell his sculptures for 1000 bolivares (over $200), but he would happily exchange a sculpture for a particularly rare balm for the joints, which he uses to massage his sore wrists and shoulders after a long day of woodcarving.

At the trueque we trade in the local currency, Sanareños, which have no monetary value.  They are produced for the purpose of exchange, and after participating in three barter markets, participants receive 100 Sanareños to further promote the exchange; he passes around the small square bills for demonstration. The idea is to encourage exchange rather than accumulation of wealth.  The idea makes sense, particularly in light of the most recent collapse of the US housing market and the bailout of the banks.  Some economists such as James Galbraith critiqued Obama’s so-called economic stimulus package, arguing if you bailout the rich, they will save money in times of economic strain, but if you bail out the working class, they will have no other option but to put most of the money back into circulation, thereby truly stimulating the economy.

On Friday morning, I arrive at the trueque, which is held in a large gymnasium in the center of town, with a passionfruit cheesecake, and a frilly, black shirt to exchange.  I fill out a form listing my products and wait for the members of the Value and Quality Committee to stop at my table and suggest a price for the cake. 5 sanareños a slice, 20 for the shirt.  Not bad, considering that a half-liter of cocuy, the local moonshine which is made from cactus and tastes rather like mezcal, goes for 20 sanareños. 

Others filter slowly into the gymnasium, arranging their products on various tables, the prices marked with pieces of masking tape.  Sharing the table with me is a woman with a range of seedlings in black plastic bags and plastic bags of goat manure.  To my left, a woman with small bags of oregano and other herbs, bottles of cocuy, and small bars of goat fat, which people use as a moisturizer and to help scars to heal.  At a table in the center are the truequeritos, a group of children about 6-12 years old, wearing matching shirts and blue baseball caps, spooning quesillo, Venezuelan flan, into cups. Next to them sits an artesan, who arranges his leather wallets, keychains and other small trinkets on the table. Others sit before tables of fresh vegetables, organized in colorful piles, used clothing, baked goods. There is even someone selling bags of chemical fertilizer.

There are about 50 participants in all, a small number in comparison to the 80-100 or so participants who normally join in, but now everyone is busy preparing for the upcoming presidential elections.  After a short convocation, the trueque begins. Participants bustle back to their tables.  Children run across the stadium, munching on pieces of cake.  “Is this seedling a yucca?” asks a 7-year-old boy. He hands the woman a piece of pumpkin in exchange and runs the seedling back to his mother. Others exchange the paper bills, which come in denominations of 1, 5, 10, 20.  The excitement is palpable.  I sit back impatiently, waiting for someone to ask about my cake.  A woman offers me two giant pincushions made out of soda bottles decorated with confetti in exchange for my shirt. I wrinkle up my nose and say they won’t fit in my suitcase.  Finally, I sell the shirt and a slice of cake.  I hurry across the gymnasium to buy a charming little jumpsuit for my baby cousin. 25 sanareños, but impossibly hip. I hurry back to my table, and the women next to me say, people stopped by for cake, but you weren’t here.

 “Geranium tea?” says Rebecca, carrying a thermos and a stack of tiny cups.  “Sure,” I say, handing over a 5 sanareño bill. She gives me four in return. Among her stack of bills are some larger squares, which look different.  “This is from a different state,” she explains, “We can go there and join in the treuque, too.” She then explains that she owns a posada, like a bed and breakfast, in Sanare. “When I want to go to the beach, I can go stay in a posada and pay with these, and when people from the posada by the beach want to stay in the mountains, they come stay here. The sanareños aren’t worth money,” she says. “They’re just a tool.”

A useful tool at that, and a far cry from the TXAI issued for the World Social Forum in 2006, which, according to The Economist, “could not buy anything really necessary, like mineral water.” By the time I had accumulated any Sanareños, all the cocuy was gone, but I did have a few lovely little trinkets, some key chains, and had sipped some delicious tea.

I take a seat next to Mario, at the closing assembly of the trueque, where discuss the positives, and suggestions for improvements for next time. I give Mario a taste of the remains of my cake, and he says, “I’d like to make a trade.” From his bag, he pulls a beautiful owl, which he sculpted from a candle.  I shake my head in astonishment. “No way,” I protest. “It’s not a fair trade.”  But he insists, “It’s not just about exchanging. What did I tell you before? It’s the joy of trueque, to give and receive in return.”

Thursday, September 13, 2012

Medical Education: Training the Next Generation of Venezuelan Doctors



“Al venir a la tierra, todo hombre tiene derecho a que se eduque, y después en pago, el deber de contribuir a la educación de los demás.” – José Martí Pérez

“On arrival to earth, every man has the right to an education, and afterwards in return, the duty to contribute to the education of others.”

Every clinic affiliated with Mision Barrio Adentro features the photo of five individuals: Simon Bolivar, Che Guevara, Fidel Castro, Hugo Chavez, and José Martí Pérez, the 19th century Cuban intellectual who dedicated his life to the liberation of Cuba.  His words infuse the daily work of the Cuban doctors and the generations of Venezuelan students who train alongside them.  The above quote introduced the presentation of a group of sixth-year medical students during their preliminary defense of their thesis for graduation of medical school. All students enrolled in MIC, the program for training in Integrative Community Medicine through Mision Barrio Adentro, must complete a thesis, which is a community health intervention designed by groups of four students regarding a public health issue which affects their community.  This group of students chose the topic of sexually transmitted infections, a taboo subject in this small Catholic community, and taught a group of over 100 adolescents in a series of 10 workshops about sexually transmitted infections which included discussions about prevention of disease, contraception, and role plays for negotiating safe sex.  One of the workshops was for the parents of these adolescents, to answer questions and encourage open conversations among family members about sexually transmitted infections.  Their conclusions: Adolescents have limited knowledge about sexually transmitted infections, and few of them receive this information from doctors. The health system has great potential to impact this population with further activities of this sort and enhance healthy behavior. The presentation and the project of this group of medical students was extremely well executed and would have stood among the best Community-Oriented Primary Care Projects, which are a graduation requirement for family medicine residents in the United States.

In the fall of 2003, when Cuban medical graduates started arriving in Venezuela for residency training in family and community medicine, many Venezuelan students started to come forward, asking to train alongside the Cuban doctors as well.  As early as 2004, some Venezuelan medical graduates joined the Cuban medical residents for training in family and community medicine, while working in Mision Barrio Adentro.  They would later by joined by several hundreds of their compatriots, who would graduate from the Latin American Medical School of Cuba between 2005 to 2008. However, these would not be enough primary care doctors to serve the entire country.  Chavez aims to train at least 30,000. Knowing that the Barrio Adentro project would not be sustainable without some way to train Venezuelan doctors, in 2003, a national commission was established to develop and oversee the National Training Program in Comprehensive Community Medicine, which brought together Cuban medical educators, members of the Venezuelan health ministry and six Venezuelan universities.  Mision Sucre, the program of the Venezuelan government designed to bring university level education directly to the working-class citizens of small towns and barrios, became the vehicle to recruit students to train with Barrio Adentro.  Since its inception, MIC has trained thousands of medical students, graduating its first class of nearly 7000 students in 2011, with about 24,000 others currently enrolled, as compared with 22,000 students enrolled in the traditional Venezuelan medical system.

In Venezuela, medical education is six years long, as in most of the world, where medical education starts immediately after secondary school, rather different from our system in the USA where everyone has to complete a bachelor’s degree prior to entering medical school. In the traditional Venezuelan medical system, people explain, students spend 5 years in the classroom, and only spend the final year seeing patients in the hospital.  This fact has been mentioned to me by many different students studying in the Barrio Adentro system, and I find it astonishing and unusual, for in other countries where I have been such as Lebanon and Brazil, students spend the first two years in classes and the final four years seeing patients. It is difficult to imagine how one could learn medicine without examining patients; to reflect personally, for me it was really only after four years of seeing patients, at the end of my second year of family medicine residency, when I really started to feel like I could direct my questions and physical exam to a particular diagnosis and plan with efficiency and rigor.  As all my professors will say, patients don`t always read the textbooks.

With this in mind, the system of medical education established as part of Barrio Adentro, initiates student contact with patients from day one. In the clinic where I am working with Dr. David, there are two premedical students who started only a month ago, one second year medical student, and two sixth-year students.  The sixth-years see patients alone at times, and can ask questions of the doctor when they have doubts. The second-year hasn’t learned to take a clinical history yet, but she and the first-years come to the clinic every morning and are involved in other activities, weighing and measuring patients, visiting families door-to-door, and helping with public health projects, putting together the family charts, helping to organize health information. 

One morning, after the early rush of patients had subsided, I sat in the back with the students and chatted.  “If it weren’t for Barrio Adentro,” I ask, “would you have been able to go to medical school?” All four students, from the pre-meds to the sixth-years, shake their heads.  Yohnny Gonzalez, one of the pre-medical students elaborates. “First of all, the medical school is in Barquisimeto (the big city an hour away), then there are the books, which are really expensive, and there’s transportation costs, and you have to rent an apartment in the city. There’s no way.”  Indeed, some of the students travel a ways from their family’s homes to take classes in the small town of Sanare.  They all receive a scholarship from the government for books and transportation. When I ask the group of eight women in the fourth-year class this question, the answer is the same.  Most of the students in the fourth-year class in Sanare have children, and almost all of them are single mothers. 

The decision to offer this critical education in the place where it is most needed serves a number of important purposes. The first is access, as the students testify.  Secondly, being from the community, the students know the needs and local culture better than anyone else, making this intervention quite different from the way in which many countries attempt to solve the problem of healthcare access, by requiring doctors to work for a short period in an underserved area after graduation from medical school. Venezuela also has this requirement; all medical graduates trained in Barrio Adentro or the traditional schools are placed in an underserved  area for one year after completing medical school before going on to train in a residency program.  However, this brings me to the third and perhaps most important purpose: sustainability and beating the brain drain.  How many medical students have I met in other countries, who had no intention of staying in their home country after completing their medical training?  The students in the traditional Venezuelan system are no different.  Certainly there are exceptions of medical graduates whom I have already mentioned who joined Mision Barrio Adentro, however, the vast majority intend to graduate and remain in Venezuela’s large cities, to work in lucrative specialties, treating the wealthy.

Let me be fair, as it is easy to demonize the wealthy specialists who drive around in cars with tinted windows, collecting the payments of patients shuffled quickly through the clinic before heading off to a golf match.  I’m as tree-hugging, immigrant-loving as the next pinko-feminist, but I grew up in a big city and couldn’t imagine settling down in a small town, so I’m not about to promise to dedicate my whole life to being a rural community doctor.  When you speak with community doctors in the US, at times they will tell you they feel isolated from their colleagues, out of touch with medical education.  I imagine that for a doctor at the community level who does not find the Barrio Adentro program a threat to their pocketbook,  the program has a lot of promise, possibly to standardize the quality of care and perhaps even the quality of life of the physicians, at the very least, those interested in teaching.  It is no small task to attempt to implement medical education and primary care on such a broad level, and one must be wary of quality control with this immense undertaking.  No doubt, some of the students will choose to go on to study in other countries, or to live and practice in Venezuela’s big cities.  However, many of them state that they intend to stay in their villages of origin, excited to participate in this revolution of medical education and to take advantage of an opportunity that they otherwise may never have had.

Monday, September 10, 2012

Maternal and Child Health: From Cuba to Venezuela


“Paola hasn’t been feeling her baby move as much since this morning, and she’s dilated three centimeters without contractions, but they wouldn’t admit her to the hospital when I brought her in this morning,” says Vilma, one of the nurses who works at the maternal home, the Mision Niño Jesus (Mission Baby Jesus) where I’ve been staying.  “In Cuba, they would admit her to the hospital,” she says.  I explain that I’m less concerned that she’s dilated 3cm, but the fact she hasn’t felt the baby move as much is a bit concerning. 

I sit down to review the chart. It’s her second pregnancy and it has been uncomplicated. The pregnancy is dated by a second trimester ultrasound, not terribly accurate with a margin of error of two weeks in either direction, she could be anywhere from 34 to 38 weeks pregnant, that is possibly preterm (less than 37 weeks pregnant). By her last menstrual period she is 42 weeks pregnant (that is 2 weeks past her due date).  “The doctor at the hospital is always changing the rules. He says one day that criteria for admission is 2cm dilation, other days its 4cm,” says Vilma. I accompany them to the hospital to see if at the very least we can perform a non-stress test, to observe the fetal heart rate for 20-30 minutes. 

We get into the ambulance which is always at the Mision Niño Jesus and go to the local hospital, a 5-minute drive away. The hospital is quite simple, all one floor with various departments. The hospital is part of the traditional medical system, and has been around since long before Chavez was elected, and is staffed primarily by doctors trained in the traditional medical system. We walk down the hallway to the obstetrical department. There are four beds for laboring patients, all empty at the moment. There is no ultrasound, only a fetal heart monitor, which appears to have capability of printing out a strip of the fetal heart rate, but there is no paper to feed into the machine. The doctor checks the patient’s cervix again, and declares it to be 2.5cm dilated and looks at the chart.  She places the fetal heart monitor on the patient for 30 seconds and then takes it off.  I ask, “Can’t we listen for longer? She was complaining of decreased fetal movement. Can we perform a non-stress test?”  She looks at me skeptically but leaves the monitor on a bit to humor me, “We don’t have the equipment here, just in Barquisimeto, at the main hospital” she says, referring to the large city, which is an hour's drive away. 

She has a point.  The machine shows the current rate in digital numbers on the screen, but without a printout of the heart rate, trying to figure out the baseline, if the variability of heart rate is appropriate, and whether the heart rate accelerates as it should is near impossible. 142, 145, 153, 156, 155, 143 beats per minute, the familiar whooshing sound of the fetal heart amplified by the Doppler.  After about 5 minutes she stops and we go to review the chart in the other room. “When was your last period?” She asks the patient. I explain that the patient told me she made up the date of her last period because she was unsure and that the dates by ultrasound don’t match the patient’s last menses by a long shot.   

Reviewing this information and realizing that this patient might be anywhere from 34 to 38 weeks pregnant, possibly preterm, she decides to send the patient to the hospital. She argues, “If she goes into labor and has a complication, she might not make it to Barquisimeto in time.”  She then explains to me that there’s no operating room at the hospital, nor an obstetrician to perform a cesarean section, just general practitioners who can handle uncomplicated vaginal deliveries with intermittent auscultation. The hospital sends all first-time mothers to the hospital in Barquisimeto because, “They often have complications.” 

As we walk out, the doctor asks, can we send her in your ambulance? Ours is broken.” But Vilma says, no we have other patients with contractions, we need our ambulance tonight.  Vilma then turns to me and says, “If you hadn’t come, they wouldn’t have taken her.” I don’t doubt it, just based on my interaction with the doctors.  

While more recently, Mision Barrio Adentro has built a number of medical centers capable of delivering tertiary care, in most cases primary care doctors practicing in the Barrio Adentro system rely on the traditional network of Venezuelan hospitals for patients in need of a higher level of care. Some of the Cuban doctors and nurses have told me stories about the difficulties they have had with transitions between Barrio Adentro in the past when transferring patients to higher levels of care in the traditional medical system.  Hospitals at times refuse admissions of patients sent by primary care doctors in Barrio Adentro and discharge them without any report whatsoever about what happened during the admission.  I personally have yet to lay my eyes on a hospital discharge summary. Paola, the patient I described above had an emergency cesarean section on arrival in Barquisimeto, and her child was born with respiratory problems; the baby is in fact still hospitalized as I write this post.

The place I’m staying is a maternal home, designed along the lines of the Cuban “hogares maternos,” which were devised as a health intervention in Cuba in 1962 as a means to encourage childbirth in hospitals as well as to improve care for mothers and infants.  Indeed the intervention did just that, increasing the number of births in hospitals from less than 20% in 1959 to nearly 100% in 2011.1 The intervention has also been credited in part with the country’s success in diminishing the infant mortality rate from 37.6 per 1000 live births in 1957 to 4.5 in 2010.1 Did I mention that’s less than the rate in the USA, 7 per 1000 live births? 2

Maternal homes were initially conceived in Cuba as a way for pregnant women living in remote areas to spend the last weeks of their pregnancy within reach of a hospital, however since their inception, they have been significantly expanded.  The maternal home of today is a multidisciplinary enterprise, complete with a team of doctors, nurses, dentists, psychologists, physical trainers, and social workers.  Patients are admitted for a number of different indications, including social determinants such as geographic distance from a hospital, teen pregnancy, obese or underweight patients, high risk patients with high blood pressure, diabetes or preeclampsia, among others. Patients are examined by a doctor once a day, fetal heart tones are auscultated and vital signs are taken twice daily. Nutritionists develop diets tailored to the patients’ conditions. In addition, physical trainers lead exercise classes, and dentists perform a full dental evaluation, pulling teeth, filling cavities, so at the moment of delivery, the mother is in an “optimal state of health by the time she gives birth,” as Arley, the director of Mision Barrio Adentro in Sanare explained to me.  I think back to the time when one of my pregnant patients requested a letter clearing her for dental work during pregnancy. This particular intervention I find interesting as recent studies have shown that poor dentition may be linked to preterm labor.3

Equally, if not more notable is the fact that few interventions have been shown to diminish the rates of preterm birth, that is, delivery before 37 weeks. For the information of non-medical folks, a full pregnancy is supposed to last 40 weeks. Preterm babies are at higher risk for multiple medical issues, such as respiratory difficulties, infections and neonatal jaundice among others. Smoking cessation appears to be effective in reducing preterm birth rates.3 Progesterone may decrease the rate for women who have had prior preterm deliveries, but for women whose only risk factor is socioeconomic status, this treatment is not indicated.3  One of the newer interventions which has been demonstrated to be effective in diminishing rates of preterm labor is prenatal group care.4 Group prenatal care refers to prenatal care visits where a group of women with a similar due date are seen together for longer visits (90 to 120 minutes long ) with a midwife or MD, where there is time to discuss issues related to pregnancy and ideally to build a support network with other women living a similar experience. There are likely many factors which contributed to the reduction in Cuba’s infant mortality rate, but the maternal homes are one of the interventions credited with this success. 

A different family doctor examines the patients daily, and they are evaluated by an OB/Gyn once a week. Dr. David explains to me that when the babies are born, for the first 7 days of life, they must been seen daily by a doctor, and then once a week until they are a month old. In addition, in Cuba, the family doctor must go to the hospital to see of their patients' newborns at least once after they are born. This all seems like a bit of overkill to me, but then, who am I to question a system that has resulted in a lower infant mortality rate than the US?

Another astonishing thing is that none of the Cuban doctors seems to have heard of screening for group B streptococcus, which is standard of care in the United States.  Group B strep is a bacteria which is commonly found on the genitalia of many women.  Women with this bacteria in the USA are treated with penicillin when in active labor. One of the coordinators of the Barrio Adentro program in Barquisimeto eventually explained to me that they do not use this test as it was not found to be useful in the Cuban context.  Group B strep screening is a core part of obstetrical and neonatal practice in the USA, with literature supporting that it saves infant lives.  I am astonished to find it is not performed in Cuba. Again, who am I to question a system that has resulted in a lower infant mortality rate than the US?

I accompany one of the patients on a visit to the gynecologist. He is one of the doctors who trained in the traditional Venezuelan medical system.  After examining the patient, he sends for some lab tests, as well as a X-ray pelvimetry. I can barely believe my eyes.  When I go home, I search the literature for articles on the utility of radiological pelvimetry, which as far as I know is so outdated I wasn’t even taught about it in medical school. Radiological pelvimetry is basically a series of X-rays of the woman’s pelvis and the baby’s head, basically to make sure that the baby can be born vaginally.  However, it doesn’t take into account the force of uterine contractions, or the ability of the baby’s head to mold during labor. I come across a few articles, one from 1964, another from 1982.  A Cochrane Review from 2000 (a very good review of few studies) demonstrates that X-rays of a woman’s pelvis and the baby’s head increase the cesarean rate, without impact on the baby’s outcome.5. In other words, not necessary, and while it’s very little radiation better to avoid the test if there is no need for it. The Cuban doctors and nurses agree, explaining to me that use this test at times to decide whether to proceed with a vaginal delivery on the labor and delivery floor, but do not routinely perform the tests on patients.

The traditional Venezuelan system frequently critiques Mision Barrio Adentro for delivering substandard care, and its medical students for being underprepared, or poorly trained as compared with their counterparts in the traditional system.  However, as far as I can tell, Mision Barrio Adentro and Mision Niño Jesus are a step in the right direction. Starting in 2009 in Venezuela, the maternal homes have been built for the purpose of housing women who in live the countryside, distant from hospitals.  They receive three meals a day as well as snacks, and are examined by a doctor daily.  In addition, there are two nurses present at the facility at all times. Health statistics show that the infant mortality rate in Venezuela has continued to decline, from 21 per 1000 live births in 2000, to 18 in 2005, to 16 in 2010.6  Critics argue that the rate of infant mortality is declining at 3.4% annually, which is no different than the 3.3% rate of decline prior to Chavez’s presidency, and that the rate is declining more rapidly in countries such as Argentina.7  Indeed, there is still a ways to go, but this increase in access to hospital deliveries and prenatal care for these women whom I’ve already met at the Mision Niño Jesus certainly seems to have promise. 

We use a fetoscope to auscultate the fetal heart rate. A fetoscope is a small metal tube which we place on the maternal abdomen to listen to the baby's heart.  Using the fetoscope is difficult. You have to be quite confident with your physical exam, palpating the mother’s belly to find the baby’s back, and tuning in to the soft beating of the fetal heart. In particular I find this difficult, as I’ve been spoiled by the Doppler, which makes finding the fetal heart rate very easy, I explain to Luiz, one of the physicians who rounds on the patients at Mision Niño Jesus. “In the USA you have many advancements,” he says, with a smile.

  1. Gorry, Conner. “Cuban Maternity Homes: A Model to Address At-Risk Pregnancy”MEDICC Review, July 2011, Vol 13, No 3.
  2. Level & Trends in Child Mortality. Report 2011. Estimates Developed by the UN Inter-agency Group for Child Mortality Estimation (UNICEF, WHO, World Bank, UN DESA, UNPD). Accessed online at http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.IMRT.IN
  3. Premature Labor. Clinical Best Practice Bulletin. BMJ Publishing Group.  Sept 2011. Accessed online at http://bestpractice.bmj.com/best-practice/monograph/1002/prevention.html
  4. Picklesimer AH, Billings D, Hale N, Blackhurst D, Covington-Kolb S. The effect of Centering Pregnancy group prenatal care on preterm birth in a low-income population. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2012 May;206(5):415.e1-7.
  5. Pattinson RC. Pelvimetry for fetal cephalic presentations at term. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2000;(2):CD000161.
  6. World Health Organization. Global Health Data Observatory. Country Statistics: Venezuela. Accessed online on 10 September 2012 at http://apps.who.int/ghodata/?vid=21200&theme=country.
  7. Francisco Rodriguez. The Unfulfilled Promises of Hugo Chavez. Foreign Affairs, March/April 2008.

Saturday, September 08, 2012

Overnight shift at the CDI


On Friday, I work the overnight shift with Dr. David at the CDI, the Integrative Diagnostic Center in Sanare. Friday night call is typically quiet, patients don’t come in much after ten.  Saturday and Sunday can be more busy, with people drinking and getting into fights or motorcycle accidents.  Dr. David explains that he’s stabilized open fractures in the trauma room, given thrombolytic therapy for acute myocardial infarction (heart attacks), and even stabilized a gunshot wound or two before sending them to a nearby hospital.  Sanare is a small city which is relatively quiet, but as he explains, Venezuela is the third most violent country in Latin America, preceded by Mexico and Colombia.  

“There’s a surgeon who works at one of the CDIs in a neighboring town with shrapnel in his foot,” he explains.  “One night when he was on call, he was operating on a patient who came in with a gunshot wound.  All of a sudden armed men burst into the operating room, pointing their guns at the operating table. The surgeon stepped aside, his back turned, and, POW! POW!” (David’s stories are always complete with sound effects) “One of the bullets that killed the patient whose life he was trying to save ricocheted off the metal table and struck his heel.” I imagine the spectacle, the OR protected by a set of double doors, a corridor and another set of double doors. Before walking through the first set of doors you must first cover your hair to keep the corridor which leads to the OR clean from bacteria. In the OR masks must be worn to avoid contamination, and of course no one can touch the sterile field without first a five-minute scrub of hands and arms up to the elbow, followed by sterile gowns and gloves.  Medicine’s sacred space, whose variables should be the patient’s anatomy, the illness, and the steadiness of a surgeon’s hand, suddenly desecrated with gunpowder and shrapnel. 

“We used to fight back,” he says, “But we’ve learned our lesson. They’ll even chase ambulances, if they haven’t finished the job.  You have to hand over the patient and step aside. They don’t look. They just shoot. And they don’t shoot to injure. They go for the head, the heart. They shoot to kill. The patients who come in here with gunshot wounds, there’s no life left to save…” he says. “But usually Fridays are quiet.” 

Last week, Dr. Arley Benitez Ruiz, the medical director of the CDI in Sanare, gave me a tour of the center. The CDI serves the various clinics in the town with various diagnostic services, including basic laboratory services (CBC, Chemistry, ESR, Fecal Studies, Urinalysis, but no cultures or serologies), X-Ray, Ultrasound, endoscopy, EKG, as well as a smattering of specialties, such as ophthalmology, optometry (which produces and provides glasses for patients), dentistry. A pair of statisticians put together the weekly reports which are sent to the central office of Mision Barrio Adentro help to direct its work, though I’m told in Cuba, there would be an entire department of statisticians. There is a central pharmacy, which often contains a broader variety of medications than is typically available in the surrounding clinics.  In addition to these services, the building houses a trauma room, an urgent care/emergency room, and three beds for hospitalizing patients, plus four or five observation beds.  Diagnoses of those hospitalized include asthma exacerbations, community acquired pneumonia, uncontrolled diabetes mellitus, among others, basically patients who might otherwise be cared for in a community hospital.  The trauma room is equipped with various emergency medications (including thrombolytic therapy for acute MI, a code cart, as well as oxygen and suction outputs).  Children and pregnant women cannot be hospitalized at the CDI and are sent to the community hospital or the larger hospital in the nearest city.

With the exception of the observation beds and trauma unit, the CDI is like a full service health center, such as Codman Square Health Center where I work in Dorchester, MA.  Except, I told Arley, in my clinic we have echocardiography and mammography as well, but no hospital beds. He explains to me that the kind of services available in Cuba might be more like what I describe, where there is a polyclinic which serves the surrounding clinics, with specialists and diagnostic services.  However, an operating room and surgeon are more critical than echocardiography in this area where simple operations such as appendectomies, or hernia repair are prohibitively expensive, but can be life saving.  In fact the CDI in a nearby town has an operating room, while the local community hospital does not.

We arrive at 4PM and place our belongings in the call room where they are two sets of bunk beds.  A lab tech, and physician caring for the hospitalized patients, a radiology tech and a nurse are also on call.  The ultrasound physician lives in a house across the street in case she is needed in the middle of the night.  We settle down in the office and the stream of patients begins.  An earache, a child with a fever or cough, a person with knee pain for the past four weeks, a patient requesting for us to review test results. 

"One doctor cures. Two doctors confuse. Three doctors kill," says David.  "An old Chinese adage," laughs Dr. Yasell, one of the other Cuban doctors who was on call the night before. I think of all my family medicine mentors would agree with that one. 
 
 After a while David launches into the rant which is the mantra of emergency room doctors everywhere. 
“This clinic is for emergencies and urgencies.  What are these people doing in the emergency room?”  He says. I just laugh and shake my head. This is an international phenomenon.  

“This one time, when I was back home,” he continues, “I put up a chart of the criteria for emergency room triage in the waiting room. I explained the codes to the patients: Red for emergencies (heart attack, stroke, trauma, etc) and Yellow for urgencies (baby with fever, pneumonia). I announced in the waiting room, ‘I just walked by all your health centers on the way here. They are all open and the doctors are inside sitting at their desks. This office is for urgencies and emergencies only. The rest of you should go home.’”  How many emergency room docs would love to do the same…Not sure if it’s a reassuring or discouraging to know that even in Cuba where healthcare is universal and free, people still walk into the ER at 3AM for constipation which they’ve had for three weeks. 

The most striking thing about Mision Barrio Adentro, is the way in which resources have been allocated.  The foundation of this system, similar to the Cuban system, are family doctors and nurses.  Then there are the diagnostic centers where there are specialists, such as pediatricians, obstetrician/gynecologists, internal medicine doctors, as well as the fellowship-trained specialists such as cardiologists, ophthalmologists, etc whom we know and love.  Note that in Cuba pediatricians, Ob-Gyn, and internal medicine doctors are considered specialists. Similarly remarkable is which specialists are most essential to serve the needs of the community. I have always, for example, thought of ophthalmology as a rather luxurious resource, however, if one were to think about planning a health system which is capable of meeting the needs of an entire population, you might need more ophthalmologists, than, say, cardiologists, as a lot of the basics of cardiology can be handled by a good primary care doctor.  

The Barrio Adentro project has also emphasized the importance of dental care and rehabilitation services.  By 2009 there were over  1600 Barrio Adentro dentistry offices operating with 4767 dentists, and by 2011, 570 rehabilitation centers were functioning. More about this in a future post.  Impressive to note as more and more research demonstrates the risk of ongoing inflammation caused by poor dentition, and the importance of regular dental care for patients with chronic diseases such as heart disease and diabetes, the US medical system has responded rather poorly.  While my clinic’s electronic medical record prompts me to ask my diabetic patients if they’ve seen a dentist recently, our public insurance systems, Medicare and Medicaid, don’t cover preventive dental services for adults.  

The rest of the night passes with few events. A farmworker comes in with a high fever, and cold symptoms, and headache, who might have dengue or leptospirosis, or perhaps just the flu. He is admitted to one of the observation beds, as there are already 7 patients admitted. A few children with colds and coughs.  When one of the mothers looks at me skeptically after hearing my speech about how the best cure for a cold is lots of fluids, some tea with lemon and honey, Dr. David chimes in. “It’s true.  Antibiotics don’t cure colds. The best treatment is some tea with lemon.  You have two doctors from two parts of the world telling you the same advice. But we’re students of the same medical school.”  I think to myself, when I return to Boston, how much I’ll miss the back up.