On Monday,
I was supposed to accompany Hilario Perez on one of his trips to the
countryside. He is one of the graduates of the first class of Venezuelan
students to study with the Cuban doctors.
Hilario, like many, spent much of his life trying to study medicine. He
is likely in his forties, too old, by traditional Venezuelan standards to enter
medical school, which don’t accept students past their early twenties. Hilario
took EMT classes with firefighters, and many different courses, but like many
of the Venezuelan students with whom I’ve spoken, he never had the resources or
the connections to be able to study medicine.
That is, until Mision Barrio
Adentro. Hilario was a student of
Dr. David. “Easily my best student,” he says. Although the contrast could not
be greater. Hilario is rather reticent,
doesn’t speak unless he has something to say, as compared to David’s endless,
animated storytelling.
Hilario is now
completing his service, two years in the countryside, in Escalera, a small village
of little over 700 people in a town typically about an hour and a half drive on
dirt roads to Sanare. However, this is the rainy season, and a massive
landslide on Sunday left 100 meters of the road under piles of dirt. With teams working to reopen the road, our
only option was to travel 2 hours out of the way to Cubiro, making the entire
trip 3 hours long, first on paved roads, but for an hour and a half on unpaved
roads on the back of a four-wheel drive pick-up truck. By the end my whole body ached from keeping
my balance and holding on to the side of the truck, as we bumped in and out of
ruts, wondering if the truck would make
it out of the next puddle of slippery mud.
“Don’t let
the chipo bite you!” said Vilma, one
of the Cuban nurses that works in the house where I’m staying in Sanare, before
I left. “Take bug spray, there’s Chagas in the countryside.” Chipo is the Venezuelan name for the “kissing
bug” that transmits Chagas disease. A
single-celled protozoan, like the one the causes malaria, Chagas disease is
transmitted by insects which often live in the earthen walls of mud houses, or
in thatched roofs. Poverty is a known risk factor for the disease. (Non-medical folks read on if you dare…) The
insects emerge at night and frequently feed on people’s faces, hence known as “kissing
bugs,” leaving traces of the parasite Trypanosoma
cruzii, behind in their feces, and leaving swelling at the site of the bite
as well as swollen glands and swollen eyelids on the side of the bite. Chronic infection with the protozoan can cause
dilated cardiomyopathy, (basically, an enlarged heart, which doesn’t pump
well), and dilation of the digestive tract, among other problems. Watch out Oprah and other acai drinkers – there
have been reports of the parasite in acai. In any case, Hilario explains, there
used to be a few cases of Chagas in Sanare, but they haven’t seen any in a
while. The house at the clinic is made
of concrete, with metal windows and a solid roof, so I feel pretty safe.
The clinic
in Escalera is small, but adequate, staffed by two nurses and a doctor. Hilario
explains that for many years, these clinics only had nurses, with an occasional
doctor who passed through. In the past the service requirement for recent
medical graduate was only six months. Now all medical gradates, regardless of
whether they have attended traditional Venezuelan medical schools or have
studied through Mission Barrio Adentro, must complete their two years of service
prior to residency. The clinic has two
rooms, a pharmacy, a waiting area with the village demographics posted on the
wall, posters encouraging breastfeeding, the newborn screening test (for phenylketonuria,
hypothyroidism, and galactosemia).
Ten
patients show up in the morning, mostly children with colds. There is a
seven-year old girl whose mother says she has a wound on her leg that resembles
leishmaniasis. We send the child to a
nearby town for treatment, as we don’t have Glucantime, the treatment for
leishmaniasis, in the clinic. In the afternoon, there is a downpour, so after
lunch at Yoselin, the nurse’s house, we sit inside and wait for the rain to
stop.
At five,
when it has cleared up, I accompany Illario to a class he is teaching in
collaboration with Mision Sucre, the new
Bolivarian mission to offer higher education to adults. He is teaching a course
about agronomy to a number of people in the town. The topic of the day is budgeting and he asks
the students to offer what they have prepared.
One of them turns in a 12-page document on a pen drive, which Hilario
opens and starts to skim on his laptop.
No one has been able to find prices for equipment. “The internet only
lists prices of equipment in other countries,” they say. Ilario suggests asking
around, or going to a market in a nearby town to ask. “You have to create a
real budget. It doesn’t have to be exact, but what you expect to spend. If you
can’t demonstrate that your project will pay for itself in five years, no one
will give you money,” he says. The end goal of the project is to develop proposals
for local agricultural projects to be submitted to the federal government for
grants and to local banks for loans.
Escalera is
an area well suited to coffee cultivation. Lining the road, we also see banana
trees, cacao, and mango and avocado trees, but coffee is what has traditionally
been grown here. We stop at the home of
one of the neighborhood leaders, whose name is also Hilario. He has a telephone
which people stop in to use and is the one who drove us to Escalera from Sanare
in his pick-up truck. He offers us coffee which he grows and roast himself. He
explains that being able to roast his own coffee and sell a finished product
makes him less susceptible to the whims of the raw coffee market.
I ask about
the consejos comunales, as I´ve been
told I should do when I’m in Escalera.
Part of the new Venezuelan constitution specified the importance of
participation in the government. An
important means of participation are these community councils, where a group of
citizens, 20 families in rural regions, can assemble to elect a rural
government and organize themselves around local projects. Anyone over fifteen
can vote, and while major decisions are made in assemblies of the entire
community, for development of projects, an executive committee is elected for
planning and logistics. In Escalera, the
consejo comunal focused on the issue of transport, a
no-brainer in a rural area, and submitted a grant to the federal government, which
promised money for a tractor and a truck to be used for road maintenance in the
community.
This new
experiment which encourages participation in local government is exciting. Having
been most accustomed to direct democracy within social movements, which had few
resources, I could never quite imagine what local participatory budgeting would
entail. But it seemed exciting to put the principles of direct democracy to
work in a very concrete setting. It is
clear however, that when you give people space to make decisions on a local
level, they come up with very appropriate and important projects, because, who
knows better than them what they need.
The two men explain to me, that the system is by no means perfect. At
times, people join in just because they want to be leaders, and don’t have an
understanding of what it means to participate in a collective project. In other
cases, government funds have been allocated, but not spent as promised and
projects were never realized. I can
imagine that the process of starting the councils is quite difficult, as it
takes time and experience to build an effective organization, and at times it
is challenging even to have a meeting, especially if the participants each give
a 10-minute speeches.
The
following morning we walk to the nearby community of Cajon, to visit a patient of Hilario’s. The house is made of mud,
interspersed with sticks of wood, but on the inside it is smooth and looks as
though it could be concrete. Magazine cutouts decorate the walls, and positive
messages are painted on the wall near the head of the bed. I think about “kissing bugs” nestling in the
crevices. Chickens hop about the
kitchen, and the chicks cheep incessantly.
The woman had a stroke a few months prior and is paralyzed below the
waist, her legs bent in contractures. Her
family members care for her, turning her every two hours to ensure she doesn’t
develop ulcers. Her daughter shows us the ulcers on her knees which are
healing. “They were much worse before,” Hilario explains, as the woman places a
pillow back between her mother’s legs to keep them from rubbing against each
other and rolls her on her side.
Caring for
a loved one is difficult under the best of circumstances. We remove the patient’s
urine catheter, explaining that it puts her at increased risk of infection, and
it would be safer to have her in diapers, but there are only 10 left. The
daughter looks at us warily and I know what she’s thinking. What happens when I get to diaper number 10
and I don’t know how to put in the catheter, or have money to buy a new one? I think about the patients at Boston Medical
Center who come in with multidrug resistant urinary tract infections. Here we are, an hour and a half drive from a
facility which can process a urine culture.
And when it pours, which is does at least every other day for six months
of the year, you can scarcely walk up the hill for the mud.
I think
back to 2008, at the training for the Fogarty Fellowship in Bethesda, MD, when a
few of the students initiated an ethical debate about the Disability Adjusted
Life Years (DALY) metric. DALY is a
metric which attempts to assess all of the effects that an illness can have on
a person, not just the effect it might have if it kills the person, but the
morbidity associated with the illness as well. But when we are assessing these
values, we must also take into account how long we expect the person to live,
which we do based on the target country for a given intervention. Thus, goes
the argument, if a person lives in a country where the life expectancy is 50
(like Afghanistan), the DALY of an illness is automatically less than if they
live in a country where the life expectancy is 80 (like the UK). Because
we already expect people in Afghanistan to live fewer years, the DALY of a
given illness is lower. In a sense, we state, as we often do, I suppose, without
saying so outright, that some lives are worth less than others.
Which part
of the picture is wrong, I’m not sure. The people in the countryside who are a
2-hour drive from the nearest health center on a sunny day? The patient with an
indwelling urinary catheter in the US who will perhaps someday pass from a urine
infection, but not before we spend millions of dollars on a hundred
hospitalizations? They are all family
members who are deeply loved.
No comments:
Post a Comment