Wednesday, April 22, 2009

World Social Forum IX, Belem, PA, Brasil

To see my photos that go along with this post, look on facebook, or you can see my Picasa here at: http://picasaweb.google.com/lara.jirmanus/WorldSocialForum2009?feat=directlink

“Baracki Obama, Iraqi banana! Baracki Obama, Iraqi banana,” (It rhymes in Portuguese, I swear.) shouts one of the bicycle taxis on the main path of the Federal Rural University of the Amazon (UFRA) campus to warn pedestrians of his approach. It’s more creative than ringing a bell, I’ll admit. He is among the many creative entrepreneurs at the 9th annual World Social Forum, a mammoth gathering which brought together over 100,000 individuals, social movements and non-profit organizations from 142 countries around the world this January.

The first World Social Forum was held in 2001, in Porto Alegre, Brazil. The forum was originally conceived as counterpoint to the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, which brings together members of the business, political and economic elite to discuss issues of political import. Criticized for excluding the voice of the people from decisions regarding the process of globalization, the World Economic Forum has been a target of large mobilizations since the 1990s. As the global justice movement began to change its organizing strategy from impeding the meetings of institutions such as the World Bank, World Trade Organization and International Monetary fund, the World Social Forum came to serve as a venue for developing and articulating alternatives to the capitalist model of globalization.

Belém received $2.5 million grant from the Brazilian federal government for the forum. Two hotels were constructed for the event, and hundreds of residents opened their homes to host forum attendees. Others stayed in schools, gymnasiums, and thousands camped like I did on the campuses of the two universities. Bathroom facilities were adequate, port-o-potties augmenting the campus facilities and cold showers, which were constructed inside a temporary wooden structure, were always available.

I stroll into the International Youth Camp for the World Social Forum as prepared as I ever am for such gatherings. A backpack, a sleeping bag, camera, some event schedules that I’ve printed out. I don’t own a tent and so after registering I walk into the first group of pitched tents I spot, duck under the caution tape and the “Universidade Federal de São João del-Rei” banner. “Bom dia, tudo bem?” I say to the two or three students sitting on the grass. They look up at me confusedly. “I just got here and don’t have a tent. Is there a chance anyone has a spot in a tent where I could stay?” I say with my most charming, unassuming smile. They all sort of look at each other and then back at me. Then a couple people speak up, “I have a spot.” And so I have a place to sleep and some instant friends from the student movement in the Federal University of São João del-Rei. They’re organized – and I quickly add myself to the 24-hour schedule to keep watch over the tents – and really friendly.

Hundreds of colorful tents fill the fields and pack the small plots of grass in front academic buildings on the UFRA campus. The main path is lined with hundreds of locals selling water, soda, beer, snacks, T-shirts and hot meals and the path is constantly filled with forum attendees, popsicle vendors, and bicycle taxis ferrying people to and from events. Banners from various student movements decorate encampments, and in the evenings, people sit out by the paths playing guitar, playing capoeira, or just drinking a beer.

My hopes for being here are modest. I want to meet people from Salvador, people from Brazil working on Palestine, perhaps some doctors doing cool work and maybe attend a session or two. It is overwhelming to make sense of the 2300 activities planned for the 6-day period, not to mention the hour-long bus ride/walk between the two campuses where the forum is being held, in 80-90O heat and 100% humidity, and the torrential rain shower that occurs daily at 2PM. As I leaf through the 100 pages of fine print schedule, I note four events for every time slot because it’s so hard to choose. I later found this strategy essential, as (no exaggeration here) only one out of every four events was actually occurring as scheduled. Events were frequently cancelled, moved without notice, including a panel with Naomi Klein, which the sound technician seemed to believe he running sound for until at least an hour after the event was scheduled to start.

The theme of the economic crisis was ubiquitous, and the urgency to develop solutions was palpable in plenary after plenary: We were right. Small and sustainable is better. Reports from various international institutions show, in spite of themselves, that big monoculture is wasteful. Unchecked capitalism and lack of financial regulation hurts everyone. But who will determine the way forward from here?

Presidents Lula da Silva of Brazil, Hugo Chávez of Venezuela, Evo Morales of Bolivia, Fernando Lugo of Paraguay, and Rafael Correa of Ecuador attended the forum, lending credibility to the event as a venue for outlining the next steps for Latin America and the global economy. However, the presidential speeches addressing the global economic and climate crises were poorly publicized and closed to all but credentialed guests –- that is, speakers, or members of a delegation from an organization. It turns out that some ordinary forum attendees were also allowed in, but for many of us the event epitomized much of our disappointment with a forum which was billed as an “open meeting place for reflective thinking, democratic debate of ideas, formulation of proposals, free exchange of experiences and interlinking for effective action.”

It was mostly outside of the organized spaces where I found much of that spirit of openness and collaboration to construct another world. I stopped at the table where forum attendees helped to plant 100,000 seedlings of eight native tree species from the Brazilian Amazon as part of an initiative to replant one billion trees in the Amazon by 2012 by the Brazilian state of Pará, the Federation of Agrarian Workers, and the Wood Exporters Association. The thousands of seedlings stretched back in tidy rows behind the volunteer who informed me that they would be replanted by members of landless people’s movements and small farmers, who live in areas which were once illegally deforested.

It felt natural to strike up a conversation with just about anyone, while in line for lunch or waiting under a tent for the daily deluge to let up. It was in such circumstances that I stumbled upon the president of a network of women’s cooperatives from India, and Ibrahim, the wacky Lebanese-Brazilian who went everywhere carrying a Palestinian flag (“So people can find us,”) and selling T-shirts and khuffiyehs out of the trunk of his rental car. I waited for an hour one day, “This’ll take two minutes,” he assured me as he bargained with the guards at the gate to let his car in and out of the UFRA campus, though he didn’t have credentials. “Remember me?” he started in, “I’m that annoying guy who’s always trying to get this car in and out of here.” When we finally made it to the other campus, the event I was hoping to attend had ended and the other event we were hoping to catch didn’t seem to be happening. We chatted up some people about Palestine and sold an “I am Palestinian” T-shirt. before heading back to shower at the camp.

When I return to the campsite, the students are playing the guitar and drinking a horrifying mixture of cheap cognac and Tang. They introduce me to another member of their carvan, Ermison, the coordinator of the student exchange program with the Landless Workers Movement, the Movimento Sem Terra (MST). (More about the MST in a future post.) Ermison is skinny, with a puffy fro and a uni-brow. We walk to buy some beer for the group and he tells me about the program he helped to organize, where students spend a week in courses about the history of the struggle of small farmers in Brazil followed by a week living with a family on a an MST settlement in a rural area. Many of the students at the campsite have just returned from the program. When we return, he asks where I’m staying. “I have a bunch of tents in another campsite,” he says. “I don’t even stay there all the time, I usually stay at the Via Campesina camp (That’s the international network of agrarian social movements, of which the MST is part). That’s where the people are,” he says. I smile and don’t say anything. He’s perhaps 21… I assure him that I’m happy where I am, staying in the tent of one of his perfectly nice, ahem, innocuous classmates.

The next night a bunch of us go to the Via Campesina party. Ermison’s there, holding hands with a cute blonde who participated in the exchange program. He comes out to me and shouts in my ear over the loud forro music. “The people in the camp where we’re staying, those are all students. This is where the people are,” he says, gleaming. I smile back, I can’t resist. “And you are?” “A student,” he says, “But I prefer to be here, with the people.” I just dance. Self-awareness can wait for another day. After the party ends we head back to the camp for more cheap cognac and beer. Ermison’s blonde has disappeared, but he finds a classmate to make out with by the small campfire. Free love, alive and well at the Brazilian, I mean, World Social Forum.

The last day of the World Social forum is for the Assemblies. There are assemblies for all of the themes emphasized at the forum: Human Rights, Workers Rights, Peace, Indigenous Peoples, the Environment, the Global Economy, among others. The task of the Assemblies is to author declarations and approve international days of action for the Assembly of Assemblies on the final afternoon. I sit down for lunch next to a group of Latin American artists and educators. It’s surprising to come across Spanish-speakers, as almost everyone at the social forum is Brazilian. Luvél is from Cuba, and as we wait for the rain to stop so that the Assembly of Assemblies can begin (two hours late in a muddy, muddy field) he tells me about the Education Assembly, which he attended. “We were very critical of the forum,” he tells me. “It was more of an exercise in activist tourism than a forum for real discussions to build another world.” He words summed it up perfectly. Granted it was a pleasure to be in a space where indigenous peoples from the Brazilian Amazon could gather to meet and also to share their culture with forum attendees, wearing traditional clothing and painting themselves and willing (paying) strangers. But most of the interaction among people from different backgrounds took place in the form of snapping pictures rather than meaningful discussions about each others’ work. People in any sort of “native” dress could barely walk a few steps without being stopped for a photo. Even I, when walking with the small contingent from Palestine, would draw the attention of activist tourists. “You’re from Palestine? É mesmo! Can we take a picture of/with you?” Admittedly, the positive attention was a nice change from the attitude of the mainstream media, however, I question how profound the understanding was. The forum was carnival meets conference, and the structure of the events—panels where experts addressed rooms full of silent listeners—left little space for true exchanges of experiences and ideas to occur.

So what is the solution? Do we know how to organize a forum that is not just another conference? Thinking back to my experiences with planning the Boston Social Forum in 2003, I recognize the challenge of creating spaces where meaningful exchanges of ideas can take place. Yet we’re investing such time and resources in social forums that we should be able to create well-facilitated spaces for the very kinds of discussions that will allow us to learn from each others’ work, and not just leave after six days feeling like we’ve been in an intense, albeit poorly organized, series of university courses. Ultimately, I’m of the opinion that it is more important to focus on local work than plan monstrous events so diffuse and chaotic that it is difficult to determine whether they really do articulate any sort of consensus about the way forward for the planet.

As I trudge across the muddy field where the Assembly of Assemblies is being held, I question the utility of the declarations that will live on the forum website, perhaps be reprinted in the alternative media, which were approved by a mix of people who represent organizations with thousands of members and others who represent only themselves, knowing full well that not even UN resolutions are binding. I run into some of the students from my campsite. They are excited. Two members of the group, Timóteo and Rafael, set to music a poem written by a Costa Rican politician. They will perform it for the hundreds of people at the end of the assembly.

When they get on stage, we work our way to the front to take pictures. The crowd joins in the chorus, “Levante las manos, para un mundo mejor.” It’s a little cheesy, but the tune is sweet. I look back at the crowd. Everyone, raising their hands to sing to the chorus. There’s something to be said for over 100,000 people, gathering for six days to discuss alternatives to capitalism and corporate driven globalization.

I get onto the plane with a notebook full of contacts and a bag full of literature. It’s nice to know that all those people exist, although it would have been nice to talk to them more, instead of spending the whole time hustling from one lecture to the next. I can’t say I agree that it was worth the immense investment of time and resources, but it’s nice to know that those people are out there.

No comments: