Monday, September 10, 2012

Maternal and Child Health: From Cuba to Venezuela


“Paola hasn’t been feeling her baby move as much since this morning, and she’s dilated three centimeters without contractions, but they wouldn’t admit her to the hospital when I brought her in this morning,” says Vilma, one of the nurses who works at the maternal home, the Mision Niño Jesus (Mission Baby Jesus) where I’ve been staying.  “In Cuba, they would admit her to the hospital,” she says.  I explain that I’m less concerned that she’s dilated 3cm, but the fact she hasn’t felt the baby move as much is a bit concerning. 

I sit down to review the chart. It’s her second pregnancy and it has been uncomplicated. The pregnancy is dated by a second trimester ultrasound, not terribly accurate with a margin of error of two weeks in either direction, she could be anywhere from 34 to 38 weeks pregnant, that is possibly preterm (less than 37 weeks pregnant). By her last menstrual period she is 42 weeks pregnant (that is 2 weeks past her due date).  “The doctor at the hospital is always changing the rules. He says one day that criteria for admission is 2cm dilation, other days its 4cm,” says Vilma. I accompany them to the hospital to see if at the very least we can perform a non-stress test, to observe the fetal heart rate for 20-30 minutes. 

We get into the ambulance which is always at the Mision Niño Jesus and go to the local hospital, a 5-minute drive away. The hospital is quite simple, all one floor with various departments. The hospital is part of the traditional medical system, and has been around since long before Chavez was elected, and is staffed primarily by doctors trained in the traditional medical system. We walk down the hallway to the obstetrical department. There are four beds for laboring patients, all empty at the moment. There is no ultrasound, only a fetal heart monitor, which appears to have capability of printing out a strip of the fetal heart rate, but there is no paper to feed into the machine. The doctor checks the patient’s cervix again, and declares it to be 2.5cm dilated and looks at the chart.  She places the fetal heart monitor on the patient for 30 seconds and then takes it off.  I ask, “Can’t we listen for longer? She was complaining of decreased fetal movement. Can we perform a non-stress test?”  She looks at me skeptically but leaves the monitor on a bit to humor me, “We don’t have the equipment here, just in Barquisimeto, at the main hospital” she says, referring to the large city, which is an hour's drive away. 

She has a point.  The machine shows the current rate in digital numbers on the screen, but without a printout of the heart rate, trying to figure out the baseline, if the variability of heart rate is appropriate, and whether the heart rate accelerates as it should is near impossible. 142, 145, 153, 156, 155, 143 beats per minute, the familiar whooshing sound of the fetal heart amplified by the Doppler.  After about 5 minutes she stops and we go to review the chart in the other room. “When was your last period?” She asks the patient. I explain that the patient told me she made up the date of her last period because she was unsure and that the dates by ultrasound don’t match the patient’s last menses by a long shot.   

Reviewing this information and realizing that this patient might be anywhere from 34 to 38 weeks pregnant, possibly preterm, she decides to send the patient to the hospital. She argues, “If she goes into labor and has a complication, she might not make it to Barquisimeto in time.”  She then explains to me that there’s no operating room at the hospital, nor an obstetrician to perform a cesarean section, just general practitioners who can handle uncomplicated vaginal deliveries with intermittent auscultation. The hospital sends all first-time mothers to the hospital in Barquisimeto because, “They often have complications.” 

As we walk out, the doctor asks, can we send her in your ambulance? Ours is broken.” But Vilma says, no we have other patients with contractions, we need our ambulance tonight.  Vilma then turns to me and says, “If you hadn’t come, they wouldn’t have taken her.” I don’t doubt it, just based on my interaction with the doctors.  

While more recently, Mision Barrio Adentro has built a number of medical centers capable of delivering tertiary care, in most cases primary care doctors practicing in the Barrio Adentro system rely on the traditional network of Venezuelan hospitals for patients in need of a higher level of care. Some of the Cuban doctors and nurses have told me stories about the difficulties they have had with transitions between Barrio Adentro in the past when transferring patients to higher levels of care in the traditional medical system.  Hospitals at times refuse admissions of patients sent by primary care doctors in Barrio Adentro and discharge them without any report whatsoever about what happened during the admission.  I personally have yet to lay my eyes on a hospital discharge summary. Paola, the patient I described above had an emergency cesarean section on arrival in Barquisimeto, and her child was born with respiratory problems; the baby is in fact still hospitalized as I write this post.

The place I’m staying is a maternal home, designed along the lines of the Cuban “hogares maternos,” which were devised as a health intervention in Cuba in 1962 as a means to encourage childbirth in hospitals as well as to improve care for mothers and infants.  Indeed the intervention did just that, increasing the number of births in hospitals from less than 20% in 1959 to nearly 100% in 2011.1 The intervention has also been credited in part with the country’s success in diminishing the infant mortality rate from 37.6 per 1000 live births in 1957 to 4.5 in 2010.1 Did I mention that’s less than the rate in the USA, 7 per 1000 live births? 2

Maternal homes were initially conceived in Cuba as a way for pregnant women living in remote areas to spend the last weeks of their pregnancy within reach of a hospital, however since their inception, they have been significantly expanded.  The maternal home of today is a multidisciplinary enterprise, complete with a team of doctors, nurses, dentists, psychologists, physical trainers, and social workers.  Patients are admitted for a number of different indications, including social determinants such as geographic distance from a hospital, teen pregnancy, obese or underweight patients, high risk patients with high blood pressure, diabetes or preeclampsia, among others. Patients are examined by a doctor once a day, fetal heart tones are auscultated and vital signs are taken twice daily. Nutritionists develop diets tailored to the patients’ conditions. In addition, physical trainers lead exercise classes, and dentists perform a full dental evaluation, pulling teeth, filling cavities, so at the moment of delivery, the mother is in an “optimal state of health by the time she gives birth,” as Arley, the director of Mision Barrio Adentro in Sanare explained to me.  I think back to the time when one of my pregnant patients requested a letter clearing her for dental work during pregnancy. This particular intervention I find interesting as recent studies have shown that poor dentition may be linked to preterm labor.3

Equally, if not more notable is the fact that few interventions have been shown to diminish the rates of preterm birth, that is, delivery before 37 weeks. For the information of non-medical folks, a full pregnancy is supposed to last 40 weeks. Preterm babies are at higher risk for multiple medical issues, such as respiratory difficulties, infections and neonatal jaundice among others. Smoking cessation appears to be effective in reducing preterm birth rates.3 Progesterone may decrease the rate for women who have had prior preterm deliveries, but for women whose only risk factor is socioeconomic status, this treatment is not indicated.3  One of the newer interventions which has been demonstrated to be effective in diminishing rates of preterm labor is prenatal group care.4 Group prenatal care refers to prenatal care visits where a group of women with a similar due date are seen together for longer visits (90 to 120 minutes long ) with a midwife or MD, where there is time to discuss issues related to pregnancy and ideally to build a support network with other women living a similar experience. There are likely many factors which contributed to the reduction in Cuba’s infant mortality rate, but the maternal homes are one of the interventions credited with this success. 

A different family doctor examines the patients daily, and they are evaluated by an OB/Gyn once a week. Dr. David explains to me that when the babies are born, for the first 7 days of life, they must been seen daily by a doctor, and then once a week until they are a month old. In addition, in Cuba, the family doctor must go to the hospital to see of their patients' newborns at least once after they are born. This all seems like a bit of overkill to me, but then, who am I to question a system that has resulted in a lower infant mortality rate than the US?

Another astonishing thing is that none of the Cuban doctors seems to have heard of screening for group B streptococcus, which is standard of care in the United States.  Group B strep is a bacteria which is commonly found on the genitalia of many women.  Women with this bacteria in the USA are treated with penicillin when in active labor. One of the coordinators of the Barrio Adentro program in Barquisimeto eventually explained to me that they do not use this test as it was not found to be useful in the Cuban context.  Group B strep screening is a core part of obstetrical and neonatal practice in the USA, with literature supporting that it saves infant lives.  I am astonished to find it is not performed in Cuba. Again, who am I to question a system that has resulted in a lower infant mortality rate than the US?

I accompany one of the patients on a visit to the gynecologist. He is one of the doctors who trained in the traditional Venezuelan medical system.  After examining the patient, he sends for some lab tests, as well as a X-ray pelvimetry. I can barely believe my eyes.  When I go home, I search the literature for articles on the utility of radiological pelvimetry, which as far as I know is so outdated I wasn’t even taught about it in medical school. Radiological pelvimetry is basically a series of X-rays of the woman’s pelvis and the baby’s head, basically to make sure that the baby can be born vaginally.  However, it doesn’t take into account the force of uterine contractions, or the ability of the baby’s head to mold during labor. I come across a few articles, one from 1964, another from 1982.  A Cochrane Review from 2000 (a very good review of few studies) demonstrates that X-rays of a woman’s pelvis and the baby’s head increase the cesarean rate, without impact on the baby’s outcome.5. In other words, not necessary, and while it’s very little radiation better to avoid the test if there is no need for it. The Cuban doctors and nurses agree, explaining to me that use this test at times to decide whether to proceed with a vaginal delivery on the labor and delivery floor, but do not routinely perform the tests on patients.

The traditional Venezuelan system frequently critiques Mision Barrio Adentro for delivering substandard care, and its medical students for being underprepared, or poorly trained as compared with their counterparts in the traditional system.  However, as far as I can tell, Mision Barrio Adentro and Mision Niño Jesus are a step in the right direction. Starting in 2009 in Venezuela, the maternal homes have been built for the purpose of housing women who in live the countryside, distant from hospitals.  They receive three meals a day as well as snacks, and are examined by a doctor daily.  In addition, there are two nurses present at the facility at all times. Health statistics show that the infant mortality rate in Venezuela has continued to decline, from 21 per 1000 live births in 2000, to 18 in 2005, to 16 in 2010.6  Critics argue that the rate of infant mortality is declining at 3.4% annually, which is no different than the 3.3% rate of decline prior to Chavez’s presidency, and that the rate is declining more rapidly in countries such as Argentina.7  Indeed, there is still a ways to go, but this increase in access to hospital deliveries and prenatal care for these women whom I’ve already met at the Mision Niño Jesus certainly seems to have promise. 

We use a fetoscope to auscultate the fetal heart rate. A fetoscope is a small metal tube which we place on the maternal abdomen to listen to the baby's heart.  Using the fetoscope is difficult. You have to be quite confident with your physical exam, palpating the mother’s belly to find the baby’s back, and tuning in to the soft beating of the fetal heart. In particular I find this difficult, as I’ve been spoiled by the Doppler, which makes finding the fetal heart rate very easy, I explain to Luiz, one of the physicians who rounds on the patients at Mision Niño Jesus. “In the USA you have many advancements,” he says, with a smile.

  1. Gorry, Conner. “Cuban Maternity Homes: A Model to Address At-Risk Pregnancy”MEDICC Review, July 2011, Vol 13, No 3.
  2. Level & Trends in Child Mortality. Report 2011. Estimates Developed by the UN Inter-agency Group for Child Mortality Estimation (UNICEF, WHO, World Bank, UN DESA, UNPD). Accessed online at http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.IMRT.IN
  3. Premature Labor. Clinical Best Practice Bulletin. BMJ Publishing Group.  Sept 2011. Accessed online at http://bestpractice.bmj.com/best-practice/monograph/1002/prevention.html
  4. Picklesimer AH, Billings D, Hale N, Blackhurst D, Covington-Kolb S. The effect of Centering Pregnancy group prenatal care on preterm birth in a low-income population. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2012 May;206(5):415.e1-7.
  5. Pattinson RC. Pelvimetry for fetal cephalic presentations at term. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2000;(2):CD000161.
  6. World Health Organization. Global Health Data Observatory. Country Statistics: Venezuela. Accessed online on 10 September 2012 at http://apps.who.int/ghodata/?vid=21200&theme=country.
  7. Francisco Rodriguez. The Unfulfilled Promises of Hugo Chavez. Foreign Affairs, March/April 2008.

1 comment:

Ani Mwalimu said...

Mad informative. I'm becoming much more interested in child care, birthing process, and health care. This is great food for thought. I appreciate your meticulous writing and commitment to these issues. stay well sister.