On Friday,
I work the overnight shift with Dr. David at the CDI, the Integrative
Diagnostic Center in Sanare. Friday night call is typically quiet, patients
don’t come in much after ten. Saturday
and Sunday can be more busy, with people drinking and getting into fights or
motorcycle accidents. Dr. David explains
that he’s stabilized open fractures in the trauma room, given thrombolytic
therapy for acute myocardial infarction (heart attacks), and even stabilized a
gunshot wound or two before sending them to a nearby hospital. Sanare is a small city which is relatively
quiet, but as he explains, Venezuela is the third most violent country in Latin
America, preceded by Mexico and Colombia.
“There’s a
surgeon who works at one of the CDIs in a neighboring town with shrapnel in his
foot,” he explains. “One night when he
was on call, he was operating on a patient who came in with a gunshot
wound. All of a sudden armed men burst
into the operating room, pointing their guns at the operating table. The
surgeon stepped aside, his back turned, and, POW! POW!” (David’s stories are
always complete with sound effects) “One of the bullets that killed the patient
whose life he was trying to save ricocheted off the metal table and struck his
heel.” I imagine the spectacle, the OR protected by a set of double doors, a
corridor and another set of double doors. Before walking through the first set
of doors you must first cover your hair to keep the corridor which leads to the
OR clean from bacteria. In the OR masks must be worn to avoid contamination,
and of course no one can touch the sterile field without first a five-minute scrub
of hands and arms up to the elbow, followed by sterile gowns and gloves. Medicine’s sacred space, whose variables should
be the patient’s anatomy, the illness, and the steadiness of a surgeon’s hand, suddenly
desecrated with gunpowder and shrapnel.
“We used to
fight back,” he says, “But we’ve learned our lesson. They’ll even chase ambulances,
if they haven’t finished the job. You have
to hand over the patient and step aside. They don’t look. They just shoot. And
they don’t shoot to injure. They go for the head, the heart. They shoot to
kill. The patients who come in here with gunshot wounds, there’s no life left
to save…” he says. “But usually Fridays are quiet.”
Last week,
Dr. Arley Benitez Ruiz, the medical director of the CDI in Sanare, gave me a
tour of the center. The CDI serves the various clinics in the town with various
diagnostic services, including basic laboratory services (CBC, Chemistry, ESR,
Fecal Studies, Urinalysis, but no cultures or serologies), X-Ray, Ultrasound,
endoscopy, EKG, as well as a smattering of specialties, such as ophthalmology,
optometry (which produces and provides glasses for patients), dentistry. A pair
of statisticians put together the weekly reports which are sent to the central
office of Mision Barrio Adentro help
to direct its work, though I’m told in Cuba, there would be an entire
department of statisticians. There is a central pharmacy, which often contains
a broader variety of medications than is typically available in the surrounding
clinics. In addition to these services,
the building houses a trauma room, an urgent care/emergency room, and three
beds for hospitalizing patients, plus four or five observation beds. Diagnoses of those hospitalized include
asthma exacerbations, community acquired pneumonia, uncontrolled diabetes
mellitus, among others, basically patients who might otherwise be cared for in
a community hospital. The trauma room is
equipped with various emergency medications (including thrombolytic therapy for
acute MI, a code cart, as well as oxygen and suction outputs). Children and pregnant women cannot be
hospitalized at the CDI and are sent to the community hospital or the larger
hospital in the nearest city.
With the
exception of the observation beds and trauma unit, the CDI is like a full
service health center, such as Codman Square Health Center where I work in
Dorchester, MA. Except, I told Arley, in
my clinic we have echocardiography and mammography as well, but no hospital
beds. He explains to me that the kind of services available in Cuba might be
more like what I describe, where there is a polyclinic which serves the
surrounding clinics, with specialists and diagnostic services. However, an operating room and surgeon are
more critical than echocardiography in this area where simple operations such
as appendectomies, or hernia repair are prohibitively expensive, but can be
life saving. In fact the CDI in a nearby
town has an operating room, while the local community hospital does not.
We arrive
at 4PM and place our belongings in the call room where they are two sets of bunk
beds. A lab tech, and physician caring
for the hospitalized patients, a radiology tech and a nurse are also on
call. The ultrasound physician lives in
a house across the street in case she is needed in the middle of the
night. We settle down in the office and
the stream of patients begins. An
earache, a child with a fever or cough, a person with knee pain for the past
four weeks, a patient requesting for us to review test results.
"One doctor cures. Two doctors confuse. Three doctors kill," says David. "An old Chinese adage," laughs Dr. Yasell, one of the other Cuban doctors who was on call the night before. I think of all my family medicine mentors would agree with that one.
After a while David launches into the rant which is the mantra of emergency room doctors everywhere.
"One doctor cures. Two doctors confuse. Three doctors kill," says David. "An old Chinese adage," laughs Dr. Yasell, one of the other Cuban doctors who was on call the night before. I think of all my family medicine mentors would agree with that one.
After a while David launches into the rant which is the mantra of emergency room doctors everywhere.
“This
clinic is for emergencies and urgencies.
What are these people doing in the emergency room?” He says. I just laugh and shake my head. This
is an international phenomenon.
“This one
time, when I was back home,” he continues, “I put up a chart of the criteria
for emergency room triage in the waiting room. I explained the codes to the
patients: Red for emergencies (heart attack, stroke, trauma, etc) and Yellow
for urgencies (baby with fever, pneumonia). I announced in the waiting room, ‘I
just walked by all your health centers on the way here. They are all open and
the doctors are inside sitting at their desks. This office is for urgencies and
emergencies only. The rest of you should go home.’” How many emergency room docs would love to do
the same…Not sure if it’s a reassuring or discouraging to know that even in
Cuba where healthcare is universal and free, people still walk into the ER at
3AM for constipation which they’ve had for three weeks.
The most
striking thing about Mision Barrio
Adentro, is the way in which resources have been allocated. The foundation of this system, similar to the
Cuban system, are family doctors and nurses.
Then there are the diagnostic centers where there are specialists, such
as pediatricians, obstetrician/gynecologists, internal medicine doctors, as
well as the fellowship-trained specialists such as cardiologists,
ophthalmologists, etc whom we know and love.
Note that in Cuba pediatricians, Ob-Gyn, and internal medicine doctors
are considered specialists. Similarly remarkable is which specialists are most essential to serve the needs of the
community. I have always, for example, thought of ophthalmology as a rather
luxurious resource, however, if one were to think about planning a health
system which is capable of meeting the needs of an entire population, you might
need more ophthalmologists, than, say, cardiologists, as a lot of the basics of
cardiology can be handled by a good primary care doctor.
The Barrio Adentro project has also emphasized
the importance of dental care and rehabilitation services. By 2009 there were over 1600 Barrio Adentro dentistry offices operating
with 4767 dentists, and by 2011, 570 rehabilitation centers were functioning. More
about this in a future post. Impressive
to note as more and more research demonstrates the risk of ongoing inflammation
caused by poor dentition, and the importance of regular dental care for patients
with chronic diseases such as heart disease and diabetes, the US medical system
has responded rather poorly. While my
clinic’s electronic medical record prompts me to ask my diabetic patients if
they’ve seen a dentist recently, our public insurance systems, Medicare and
Medicaid, don’t cover preventive dental services for adults.
The rest of
the night passes with few events. A farmworker comes in with a high fever, and
cold symptoms, and headache, who might have dengue or leptospirosis, or perhaps
just the flu. He is admitted to one of the observation beds, as there are
already 7 patients admitted. A few children with colds and coughs. When one of the mothers looks at me
skeptically after hearing my speech about how the best cure for a cold is lots
of fluids, some tea with lemon and honey, Dr. David chimes in. “It’s true. Antibiotics don’t cure colds. The best
treatment is some tea with lemon. You
have two doctors from two parts of the world telling you the same advice. But
we’re students of the same medical school.”
I think to myself, when I return to Boston, how much I’ll miss the back
up.
No comments:
Post a Comment