My roommate Franklin said to me before leaving Salvador, “I went to a straight club with you, now it’s time for you to come to a gay club with me.” “Of course,” I said. “Whenever there’s music and dancing, you can count me in.”
It was surprisingly difficult to gather up a posse to go to Off Club, which is located in the tourist-fillled Barra neighborhood of Salvador. Everyone seems to have other plans. A couple of women in Franklin’s research group decline saying, they would feel “out of place”. A friend of mine says he’ll come along. “Wow, he’s a real kamikaze,” was Franklin’s reaction. “What do you mean?” I said. “You know those Japanese pilots…” “Yes, I am familiar with the term.” “Look,” says Franklin. “For a straight guy to go to a gay club in Brazil…he must be really hard hit for you is all I’m saying.” But my kamikaze calls to cancel around 10PM.
According to the Groupo Gay da Bahia (GGB), Brazil leads the world in the number of hate crimes committed against GLBT individuals, with an average of 100 people murdered annually. In Brazil, victims of homophobic violence tend to be young and of African descent (70%). The northeastern part of Brazil suffers from the highest rates of violence against gays, and during the year 2008, the state of Bahia stepped into the lead with 20 murders, followed by 19 murders in São Paulo. For the purposes of comparison, according to the FBI’s 2006 report on hate crimes, in 2006 in the United States, 1,415 sexual-orientation motivated hate crimes were committed, mostly assault, vandalism and intimidation. No murders or non-negligent manslaughters were recorded.
I found the statistic surprising when I first saw it…Brazil doesn’t stand out to me as a society which is particularly more homophobic than others which I have observed. Perhaps it is the difference in gender norms that threw me off, for example, in the United States a man dancing samba would not be considered particularly masculine. But I can’t help but feel like the society is more open when drag queens hand out flyers to straight clubs, or dance samba in the street dolled up in carnaval feathers and frill in the midst of crowds clapping and cheering, “Opa!” Or even while watching participants in a ceremony of candomblé, the religion which originated among African slaves in the state of Bahia and has been practiced for four centuries, it is difficult to avoid noting that the effeminate aspect of some of the male participants. Not to mention some of the really positive news coverage of the marital ceremony uniting two men which was held this week in a terreiro de candomblé in Lauro de Freitas, Bahia, about 30 miles from Salvador. (No, the marriage will not be recognized by the Brazilian government.)
In my albeit brief internet search I had trouble confirming the comparative data that would place Brazil ahead of all other nations in sexual-orientation motivated hate crimes; it is furthermore important to consider that many countries (and indeed many states in the US) do not collect statistics on hate crimes motivated by sexual orientation. Regardless, perhaps the word kamikaze was more appropriate than I appreciated.
We arrive at about 12:15AM…getting a ride from one of my roommate’s colleagues Ridalva and her husband, Mauricio. The club is predictably deserted when we walk in—come on, who comes to a club before at least 1AM—and ice cold, the air conditioning cranked up in anticipation of the 300 people who would soon be bouncing to electronic music within its black walls. We get a drink and settle in on an uncomfortable couch on the club’s second floor.
The entire space inside the club is designed to force people to look outward. A few couches only big enough for two. A single row of stools against the wall with tables in front of them. You can’t sit opposite anyone, or with your back to anyone. A balcony to look down at people on the dance floor below. We stand up to watch people arrive as I comment to my roommate. “You know, I feel like I’m doing an comparative study here. I’ve already been to gay clubs in 3 countries (US, Lebanon, Colombia). This would be my fourth.”
As the people slowly trickle in, I begin to make my profound observations. Clubgoers wearing shorts. That would break dress code in most clubs I’ve been to. And then perhaps an interesting finding, there are very few black men (though perhaps more than I’ve seen black residents and med students in the hospital and clinics I’ve worked in here). My friends don’t seem too surprised. “Not everyone has R$20 (about 10USD) for cover,” they say. More on this another day, but let us note once again where the legacy of slavery rears its ugly head.
There are also very, very few women, perhaps 15 to 20 in the entire club. I’ve never seen so few in a gay club, but there’s no discount for women. My friends Claudia and Roberta confirm that in Brazil, consistent at least with the US and Lebanon (correct me if I’m wrong folks), so-called “gay” clubs are not often a space for queer women. They complain that there aren’t many spaces for queer women to hang out in Salvador, but Claudia the positive side of this. “I think in Brazil we’re less ghettoized than in other places. We’re more integrated into society.” Roberta disagrees. “That’s not the way it is in São Paulo,” where Roberta is from. “There are neighborhoods where gay people live and where there are queer-friendly bars. Salvador is just a smaller city.” But that said, she continues to talk about how open she is about her personal life. “I just act like it’s normal and then it is. When I interviewed for my job here and they asked me if I was married, I said ‘Yes, I’ve been married to Claudia for 6 years,’ and people accept it. Now everyone knows.” If Salvador is so queer friendly, then where are these hate crimes happening, I wonder. Some of my friends conjecture that life in the favelas is more difficult for queer folks. Off Club is certainly in a posh neighborhood.
At 1:26AM the first shirts start to come off. “What?” I say. “OK. I haven’t seen that in a gay club before…at least not among the clubgoers.” “Oh yeah,” Franklin confirms. “See that group of guys there? I guarantee you in a few minutes they’ll be shirtless too. There’s always a group of hot guys that hang out together, and then they all take their shirts off.” Amazing…score one point Brazil.
Every few minutes Mauricio seems to run into someone else he knows, and we start joking about his secret nightlife. He laughs nervously, his arm around his wife’s waist. “Don’t feel bad if the guys here aren’t paying attention to you,” he says. “It’s not you.” But then, Franklin smiles at me, “I think you have an admirer,” he says. Now that he mentions it, that girl does sort of seem to be following me around the dance floor. Hmm…she’s pretty cute. “Aproveite!” says Ridalva. I laugh, and kinda start blushing. What do I do? Look at her? Not look at her? By the time I gather myself together, she’s already disappeared.
We go back upstairs to watch the crowd from below. As predicted the group of hot guys have tucked their shirts into their back pockets and are standing by the wall, looking bored and beautiful.
At around 4am we walk out of the club, our ears ringing from the thumping techno music. “So what did you think?” said Franklin. I give my grand cross-cultural impression: “Not so different from most clubs I've been too. I just hope everyone gets home safely.”
Sunday, December 21, 2008
Monday, November 10, 2008
Viva Obama
“Viva Obama!” Is what you hear on the streets in Bahia, the Brazilian state with the strongest African heritage…80% of residents are of African descent. When I arrived in August, I was surprised to find the familiar face of Barack Obama plastered on billboards all over town. Correio, a major newspaper, had selected the cover page with his photo for their advertising campaign.
On election night, after dinner, samba, and a disastrous attempt to revive my Spanish with some Argentine friends of my new roommate, Federico, I arrived at the Spanish club where a group of Americans had organized an event to watch the votes being tallied on CNN. At 1AM, 11PM EST I descended the dark staircase to join the party. Cheering arose from the bar below. I frantically ran down three flights of stairs to watch CNN officially call the election in Obama’s favor. There I found the welcoming faces of 20 strangers and a recent acquaintance, watching in awe as the tallies of the popular vote rolled by, state by state. We elected our first black president.
Obama’s proposed cabinet appointments have been rapidly disillusioning, not the least of which is his selection of the profoundly conservative and militaristic Rahm Emanuel for Chief of Staff. (Fear not, Israel, Emanuel is a dual citizen.) I will not dwell on the details now, because I want to take a moment to recognize the importance of what an Obama victory means for the United States, and especially to note that his victory was made possible, not just by the circumstances of recent events, or by the debacle of Bush’s eight years in the Oval Office, but by the faith and participation of thousands of people who have never felt included in the political process. By the patience of hundreds of voters who spent hours waiting their turn to vote, and who fully appreciated what a privilege it is to select the leader of the world’s dominant superpower.
Obama’s campaign for president and his election have done tremendous wonders for America’s image abroad, promising change and instilling hope in a world which has increasingly disappointed and ultimately horrified by the past 50 years of American foreign policy. Indeed this faith in the possibility of change is likely overly optimistic, and you will find some world leaders speak with a more restrained acknowledgment of Obama’s victory than others. The words of leaders in the Arab world particularly echo a guarded hope that Obama will at least rectify some of the missteps of the Bush administration.
While I was waiting for my capoeira professor to appear in Pelourinho on Wednesday, one of the tourist police struck up a conversation with me. “So, did you vote?” I nodded. “Did he win or did he lose?” he asked. I smiled. “He won. I have a black president.” The policeman smiled back. “I think it’s good. Obama is a lot like Lula,” he said, referring to Brazil’s president. “I don’t know if I’d give him that much credit,” I said.
Lula, or Luiz Inácio da Silva, Brazil’s current president, also came from modest roots, and his election in 2002 was seen to be as unlikely as that of Barack Hussein Obama. Lula is the son of working class parents from the Northeast of Brazil; he had little formal education and worked as a shoe shiner and street vendor from age 12. In Brazil, nordestinos, residents of northeastern Brazil, are stereotyped as being poor and working class, lazy, even dirty. The image is entangled in racial prejudice and the remnants of a history of over 200 years of slavery, as the Afro-Brazilian population is more concentrated in the northeast of the country. Indeed, in São Paulo, the country’s commercial capital, you may hear the word baiano, that is, a person from the province of Bahia, used as an insult by schoolchildren. Lula’s election as the president of Brazil in 2002 was a symbolic moment for Brazil and for residents of Brazil’s Northeast in particular.
This past Friday Mestre Renê, of the Associação de Capoeira Angola Navio Negreiro (Capoeira Angola Association of the Slaveship) dedicated the capoeira roda (an event where people gather to play capoeira) to Barack Obama, “A black president who will represent all of us, all black people and indigenous people in the world.” Mestre Renê’s capoeira school is located on the ground floor of his home in the 2 de Julho neighborhood of Salvador. He refers to the school as a quilombo, in reference to the autonomous hinterland settlements founded by escaped slaves during the slave trade in Brazil. After the roda he addresses the group, as is his custom, from the bench where the bateria, the percussionists for the roda, sit. Resting the berimbau, on his knee, he tucks one of his long dreadlocks back into his white tam. “We who had to bow down to white masters, and won the right to ride in the same bus as white people, to go to the same schools as white people. We too can elect a president, a black man, to be the leader of the most powerful country in the world. It would be one thing if he were he president of Brazil, or Uruguay, or wherever. But the United States of America. We have a black president for the world.”
Six years ago I was traveling in Spain just as the American invasion of Iraq was beginning. Walking down the street one evening in Barcelona, a couple of men walking behind me began to sing quietly, “Give peace a chance…” I wanted to turn around and say, “Look, two weeks ago I was at the biggest rally Boston’s ever seen. 30,000 people against the invasion of Iraq.” But I held my tongue. Now I walk down the street hoping someone will ask me where I’m from. The world is celebrating with us now, celebrating for the hope for change.
Watching Obama select his cabinet it becomes more and more evident, that if we truly want change, it will not be for the president, even our first black president who came from modest beginnings, even a former community organizer who campaigned on a platform for change, to give. If we want universal health care, a fair and sustainable economy and planet, a humane and egalitarian foreign policy, it will be for us to demand. If I hope for change it is a hope that what the world witnessed on November 4, 2008, lines of voters new and old, winding around the block, because they understand that their voice matters, will be repeated many times over in the months to come. So here’s to the election of Obama marking the beginning of an era of American democracy, which will be even more participatory, more inclusive and empowering of voices, which have long been left out of the dialogue. If we want change, it will be for us, the people, to deliver.
“Power concedes nothing without a demand. It never did and it never will." -Fredrick Douglas
“Viva Obama!” Is what you hear on the streets in Bahia, the Brazilian state with the strongest African heritage…80% of residents are of African descent. When I arrived in August, I was surprised to find the familiar face of Barack Obama plastered on billboards all over town. Correio, a major newspaper, had selected the cover page with his photo for their advertising campaign.
On election night, after dinner, samba, and a disastrous attempt to revive my Spanish with some Argentine friends of my new roommate, Federico, I arrived at the Spanish club where a group of Americans had organized an event to watch the votes being tallied on CNN. At 1AM, 11PM EST I descended the dark staircase to join the party. Cheering arose from the bar below. I frantically ran down three flights of stairs to watch CNN officially call the election in Obama’s favor. There I found the welcoming faces of 20 strangers and a recent acquaintance, watching in awe as the tallies of the popular vote rolled by, state by state. We elected our first black president.
Obama’s proposed cabinet appointments have been rapidly disillusioning, not the least of which is his selection of the profoundly conservative and militaristic Rahm Emanuel for Chief of Staff. (Fear not, Israel, Emanuel is a dual citizen.) I will not dwell on the details now, because I want to take a moment to recognize the importance of what an Obama victory means for the United States, and especially to note that his victory was made possible, not just by the circumstances of recent events, or by the debacle of Bush’s eight years in the Oval Office, but by the faith and participation of thousands of people who have never felt included in the political process. By the patience of hundreds of voters who spent hours waiting their turn to vote, and who fully appreciated what a privilege it is to select the leader of the world’s dominant superpower.
Obama’s campaign for president and his election have done tremendous wonders for America’s image abroad, promising change and instilling hope in a world which has increasingly disappointed and ultimately horrified by the past 50 years of American foreign policy. Indeed this faith in the possibility of change is likely overly optimistic, and you will find some world leaders speak with a more restrained acknowledgment of Obama’s victory than others. The words of leaders in the Arab world particularly echo a guarded hope that Obama will at least rectify some of the missteps of the Bush administration.
While I was waiting for my capoeira professor to appear in Pelourinho on Wednesday, one of the tourist police struck up a conversation with me. “So, did you vote?” I nodded. “Did he win or did he lose?” he asked. I smiled. “He won. I have a black president.” The policeman smiled back. “I think it’s good. Obama is a lot like Lula,” he said, referring to Brazil’s president. “I don’t know if I’d give him that much credit,” I said.
Lula, or Luiz Inácio da Silva, Brazil’s current president, also came from modest roots, and his election in 2002 was seen to be as unlikely as that of Barack Hussein Obama. Lula is the son of working class parents from the Northeast of Brazil; he had little formal education and worked as a shoe shiner and street vendor from age 12. In Brazil, nordestinos, residents of northeastern Brazil, are stereotyped as being poor and working class, lazy, even dirty. The image is entangled in racial prejudice and the remnants of a history of over 200 years of slavery, as the Afro-Brazilian population is more concentrated in the northeast of the country. Indeed, in São Paulo, the country’s commercial capital, you may hear the word baiano, that is, a person from the province of Bahia, used as an insult by schoolchildren. Lula’s election as the president of Brazil in 2002 was a symbolic moment for Brazil and for residents of Brazil’s Northeast in particular.
This past Friday Mestre Renê, of the Associação de Capoeira Angola Navio Negreiro (Capoeira Angola Association of the Slaveship) dedicated the capoeira roda (an event where people gather to play capoeira) to Barack Obama, “A black president who will represent all of us, all black people and indigenous people in the world.” Mestre Renê’s capoeira school is located on the ground floor of his home in the 2 de Julho neighborhood of Salvador. He refers to the school as a quilombo, in reference to the autonomous hinterland settlements founded by escaped slaves during the slave trade in Brazil. After the roda he addresses the group, as is his custom, from the bench where the bateria, the percussionists for the roda, sit. Resting the berimbau, on his knee, he tucks one of his long dreadlocks back into his white tam. “We who had to bow down to white masters, and won the right to ride in the same bus as white people, to go to the same schools as white people. We too can elect a president, a black man, to be the leader of the most powerful country in the world. It would be one thing if he were he president of Brazil, or Uruguay, or wherever. But the United States of America. We have a black president for the world.”
Six years ago I was traveling in Spain just as the American invasion of Iraq was beginning. Walking down the street one evening in Barcelona, a couple of men walking behind me began to sing quietly, “Give peace a chance…” I wanted to turn around and say, “Look, two weeks ago I was at the biggest rally Boston’s ever seen. 30,000 people against the invasion of Iraq.” But I held my tongue. Now I walk down the street hoping someone will ask me where I’m from. The world is celebrating with us now, celebrating for the hope for change.
Watching Obama select his cabinet it becomes more and more evident, that if we truly want change, it will not be for the president, even our first black president who came from modest beginnings, even a former community organizer who campaigned on a platform for change, to give. If we want universal health care, a fair and sustainable economy and planet, a humane and egalitarian foreign policy, it will be for us to demand. If I hope for change it is a hope that what the world witnessed on November 4, 2008, lines of voters new and old, winding around the block, because they understand that their voice matters, will be repeated many times over in the months to come. So here’s to the election of Obama marking the beginning of an era of American democracy, which will be even more participatory, more inclusive and empowering of voices, which have long been left out of the dialogue. If we want change, it will be for us, the people, to deliver.
“Power concedes nothing without a demand. It never did and it never will." -Fredrick Douglas
Sunday, October 19, 2008
If your only involvement in democracy is in a voting booth 10 minutes a year, then that's all the democracy you're going to get. - Ventura A.E.Simmons
Ironically, here in Corte de Pedra, a 4-hour bus ride from Salvador, I am most able to read the news and try to sort out the mind-boggling details of the global economic crisis. My opinion remains the same, whenever politicians want to make important decisions about the future of the country they just talk about “the economy,” and everyone turns off their brain because it’s too confusing so they can do what they please (or more accurately, what their campaign contributors please). In the midst of the current crisis of economy/democracy that’s happening in the US, it has been interesting to witness democracy play out here in Brazil. A couple weeks ago, now, the local elections for mayor and governor were held across the country.
In the countryside, where I’ve been working, people take elections very seriously, painting the name and party number of their preferred candidate inside a heart on the side of their houses. At times people even get into fistfights over candidates. It’s impossible to escape the elections, because in the 3 months leading up to them, the parties hire cars to drive around blasting the campaign themes of their candidates.
In Brazil voting is obligatory. If you can’t return to your local district to vote, you have to justify your absence. Otherwise there are fines to pay. If you want any sort of official paperwork from the government, for example, a passport, you must demonstrate that you voted in the last elections. Voting takes place on a Sunday, so that work should be less of a conflict. The contrast with our electoral system in the US is interesting, where it’s a struggle to get out the vote, and to use the words of my friend Santiago in New Mexico, where many people don’t feel invited to participate in the electoral process. Of course the obligatory voting doesn’t guarantee optimal participation either; particularly in the interior, in rural communities where jobs are scarce and there are fewer prying eyes to enforce election law, votes are at times, unfortunately, bought and sold.
After the polls close at 5PM, people gather to watch as the results are tallied and projected on screens outdoors under tents around town. My friends Maria and André invited me for the commemoration of the elections in Rio Vermelho, a neighborhood known to be a PT stronghold. We grab an acarajé (a shrimp based fritter, native to Bahia) from a nearby stand and sit on a bench listening to a guitarist strumming a samba across the street from the tent. The tent is thronged with people wearing red PT T-shirts; occasional cheers erupt from the crowd as their candidate Pinheiro climbs in the polls. Nearby is a stand where you can buy caipirinhas and caipiroskas, your choice of crushed fruit with cane liquor or vodka. The scene reminds me of numerous election night parties I’ve spent at various campaign headquarters. (Got to admit, the drinks here are tastier, though.) When the PT theme blasts over the sound system, Maria and André sing along, “Lula é meu presidente, Wagner governador, quero minha cidade descente, sou Pinheiro, sou mais Salvador. Eu voto 13. É 13, é 13, é 13, é 13, é 13.” 13 is the PT’s number.
Brazil has a multiparty system, with over 20 political parties, though about five parties dominate the political scene. It was not always this way, however. During the military dictatorship, which only ended in 1985, only two political parties were allowed: the Brazilian Democratic Movement (MDB) and the National Alliance for Renewal, ARENA (do all countries in Latin America have an evil party named ARENA, or is it just me?), though many affectionately referred to the two parties as “Yes” and “Yes, sir.” At a time when even union meetings were illegal, manufacturing workers in Sao Paulo began organizing the beginnings of the PT, the Brazilian Worker’s Party. It was from this struggle that emerged the party which has held the presidency of the state of Brazil for the past 6 years.
Looking from the outside in at this history of a people who have fought in the face of formidable odds for a voice in their government, leads me to reflect on the government of my own country. Over a week ago I called the Congressional switchboard to urge my representative to oppose the $700 billion bailout of Wall Street. At the very least, I told the intern who answered the phone, they could spend that money to pay off mortgages of homeowners, thereby securing the futures of thousands of families who were victims of predatory lending practices and protecting the livelihood of thousands of our most vulnerable communities whose property values are plummeting due to countless foreclosures. Is it any surprise that Paulson, former CEO if Goldman Sachs who possesses $523.5 million in the company’s stock opposed placing limits on bank CEO compensation as part of the proposal? I waited 5 minutes for my call to be connected the lines were so busy. I’ve never experienced that before. I wonder how many other Americans were calling at that moment, and though the New York Times claimed that the day after the House rejected the initial bailout proposal the phones of Congress people were ringing off the hook with calls from people whose stocks had dropped, I find it hard to believe that the majority of Americans tying up the lines last week were calling to ask Congress to rescue their stock options. We have two parties in the US. I dare say you can guess what I would call them, affectionately, of course. But there’s no military dictatorship to scare us from of starting another, or demanding a runoff system of voting which might make it easier for at least a third party to grow, free from the fear of the spoiler effect.
Meanwhile the whole world is watching the stock market and the US presidential election. While the dermatology resident I was shadowing in leprosy clinic stepped out of the room the other day, a patient asked me. “Do you think Obama will win? It seems to me like he’s a peaceful guy. Not like the other one. We could really use a peaceful president for the US. There’s too much violence in the world.” I shrugged and replied, “I don’t know, but I think the whole world should get to vote in our elections. The results affect you just as much as us.”
Back at the house attached to the leishmania clinic in Corte de Pedra I sit counting charts, “16547, 16548…” My boss, Edgar walks in and kisses me on the head. “I hear you’ve been campaigning for the PT,” he says. “Uh oh, Lara,” says Paulo Machado, the dermatologist who runs the leprosy clinic in Salvador’s Hospital das Clinicas. “Looks like you have a political problem on your hands.” I laugh. Grabbing a snack in Rio Vermelho on election night is hardly campaigning. “You really should have looked at my c.v. before letting me come here, or at least googled me,” I reply.
Ironically, here in Corte de Pedra, a 4-hour bus ride from Salvador, I am most able to read the news and try to sort out the mind-boggling details of the global economic crisis. My opinion remains the same, whenever politicians want to make important decisions about the future of the country they just talk about “the economy,” and everyone turns off their brain because it’s too confusing so they can do what they please (or more accurately, what their campaign contributors please). In the midst of the current crisis of economy/democracy that’s happening in the US, it has been interesting to witness democracy play out here in Brazil. A couple weeks ago, now, the local elections for mayor and governor were held across the country.
In the countryside, where I’ve been working, people take elections very seriously, painting the name and party number of their preferred candidate inside a heart on the side of their houses. At times people even get into fistfights over candidates. It’s impossible to escape the elections, because in the 3 months leading up to them, the parties hire cars to drive around blasting the campaign themes of their candidates.
In Brazil voting is obligatory. If you can’t return to your local district to vote, you have to justify your absence. Otherwise there are fines to pay. If you want any sort of official paperwork from the government, for example, a passport, you must demonstrate that you voted in the last elections. Voting takes place on a Sunday, so that work should be less of a conflict. The contrast with our electoral system in the US is interesting, where it’s a struggle to get out the vote, and to use the words of my friend Santiago in New Mexico, where many people don’t feel invited to participate in the electoral process. Of course the obligatory voting doesn’t guarantee optimal participation either; particularly in the interior, in rural communities where jobs are scarce and there are fewer prying eyes to enforce election law, votes are at times, unfortunately, bought and sold.
After the polls close at 5PM, people gather to watch as the results are tallied and projected on screens outdoors under tents around town. My friends Maria and André invited me for the commemoration of the elections in Rio Vermelho, a neighborhood known to be a PT stronghold. We grab an acarajé (a shrimp based fritter, native to Bahia) from a nearby stand and sit on a bench listening to a guitarist strumming a samba across the street from the tent. The tent is thronged with people wearing red PT T-shirts; occasional cheers erupt from the crowd as their candidate Pinheiro climbs in the polls. Nearby is a stand where you can buy caipirinhas and caipiroskas, your choice of crushed fruit with cane liquor or vodka. The scene reminds me of numerous election night parties I’ve spent at various campaign headquarters. (Got to admit, the drinks here are tastier, though.) When the PT theme blasts over the sound system, Maria and André sing along, “Lula é meu presidente, Wagner governador, quero minha cidade descente, sou Pinheiro, sou mais Salvador. Eu voto 13. É 13, é 13, é 13, é 13, é 13.” 13 is the PT’s number.
Brazil has a multiparty system, with over 20 political parties, though about five parties dominate the political scene. It was not always this way, however. During the military dictatorship, which only ended in 1985, only two political parties were allowed: the Brazilian Democratic Movement (MDB) and the National Alliance for Renewal, ARENA (do all countries in Latin America have an evil party named ARENA, or is it just me?), though many affectionately referred to the two parties as “Yes” and “Yes, sir.” At a time when even union meetings were illegal, manufacturing workers in Sao Paulo began organizing the beginnings of the PT, the Brazilian Worker’s Party. It was from this struggle that emerged the party which has held the presidency of the state of Brazil for the past 6 years.
Looking from the outside in at this history of a people who have fought in the face of formidable odds for a voice in their government, leads me to reflect on the government of my own country. Over a week ago I called the Congressional switchboard to urge my representative to oppose the $700 billion bailout of Wall Street. At the very least, I told the intern who answered the phone, they could spend that money to pay off mortgages of homeowners, thereby securing the futures of thousands of families who were victims of predatory lending practices and protecting the livelihood of thousands of our most vulnerable communities whose property values are plummeting due to countless foreclosures. Is it any surprise that Paulson, former CEO if Goldman Sachs who possesses $523.5 million in the company’s stock opposed placing limits on bank CEO compensation as part of the proposal? I waited 5 minutes for my call to be connected the lines were so busy. I’ve never experienced that before. I wonder how many other Americans were calling at that moment, and though the New York Times claimed that the day after the House rejected the initial bailout proposal the phones of Congress people were ringing off the hook with calls from people whose stocks had dropped, I find it hard to believe that the majority of Americans tying up the lines last week were calling to ask Congress to rescue their stock options. We have two parties in the US. I dare say you can guess what I would call them, affectionately, of course. But there’s no military dictatorship to scare us from of starting another, or demanding a runoff system of voting which might make it easier for at least a third party to grow, free from the fear of the spoiler effect.
Meanwhile the whole world is watching the stock market and the US presidential election. While the dermatology resident I was shadowing in leprosy clinic stepped out of the room the other day, a patient asked me. “Do you think Obama will win? It seems to me like he’s a peaceful guy. Not like the other one. We could really use a peaceful president for the US. There’s too much violence in the world.” I shrugged and replied, “I don’t know, but I think the whole world should get to vote in our elections. The results affect you just as much as us.”
Back at the house attached to the leishmania clinic in Corte de Pedra I sit counting charts, “16547, 16548…” My boss, Edgar walks in and kisses me on the head. “I hear you’ve been campaigning for the PT,” he says. “Uh oh, Lara,” says Paulo Machado, the dermatologist who runs the leprosy clinic in Salvador’s Hospital das Clinicas. “Looks like you have a political problem on your hands.” I laugh. Grabbing a snack in Rio Vermelho on election night is hardly campaigning. “You really should have looked at my c.v. before letting me come here, or at least googled me,” I reply.
Sunday, September 21, 2008
Salvador, Brazil
Sorry, people keep bugging me that I haven’t sent updates yet. So, here goes, in response to popular demand, a short and sweet update. I’m going to try and post to my blog once a week, short things, so the first one, of little substance, just some impressions. So, I arrived in Salvador, the capital of the Brazilian state of Bahia a month ago now, and it’s really been beach, capoeira, parties and dancing. And what’s not to love, the weather always seems to be 80 degrees, and usually sunny. I’m staying in an apartment owned by Cornell University, but will soon be moving to a new place with a gorgeous view of the ocean, and a 5 minute walk from the beach. I’ll be living there with a couple of Brazilian researchers who have recently moved to Salvador.
One of the best parts of my time here so far has been dancing forro (pronounced fo-HO), which is native to the northeast of Brazil, and is danced with a partner to the swinging music of accordion, zabumba (a type of drum) and triangle. How those instruments create the most charming and cheerful music imaginable is a mystery, but I promise you they do. I think it was watching Rob, an American medical student living in the Cornell apartment with me, who is utterly enamored with forro, sway from side to side, with his hands in the air as though holding an imaginary partner, that helped me truly appreciate its charm. Those of you in Boston who do dance forro, I beg you to take him with you sometime. You will not regret it. :)
My Spanish has been slowly but surely converting into Portuguese, and the mishaps in the beginning, were if anything, a reason for me to walk around all day smiling at everyone’s good natured attempts to understand me. I think my favorite story being when I was looking for the mall, so I could get some passport photos taken and I stopped to have a conversation which translates as the following.
Me: Where is the evil? (ie. Onde esta o mall?)
Guy selling fruits: The what? (O que?)
Me: (Hmm…maybe the word isn’t mall) The building with many businesses inside. (O edifiço com muitos negocios la dentro)
Guy: Oh, the mall. (O…o shopping)
And that was how I learned that mall in Portuguese, or at least in Brazil is “shopping.” Well, you get to decide whether I misspoke.
My work has only just begun in earnest. I’ve been spending some days in various clinics at the Hospital das Clinicas, affiliated with UFBA, the Federal University of Bahia, seeing mostly patients with diseases that we don’t see much of in the US, like leprosy, rheumatic fever, HTLV-1 (which for those of you budding neurologists, I would suggest you come check out, because it’s really interesting). So, why am I here, except of course to train capoeira (more groups than you can count here in Bahia, where the martial art was born), and soak up the sun and music. I am here to study cutaneous leishmaniasis.
Leishmaniasis is not common in the city of Salvador, but is endemic to parts of the interior of Brazil, especially in the areas where rainforest has been cleared to create large plantations. If you dare to glance at my photos (I will label them carefully I promise, so you can avoid gross pictures if you wish) you will see the classic lesions. Basically, leishmaniasis is caused by
a protozoan (small organism like malaria) that can be injected into your skin by the bite of a sandfly. The bite then grows into an ulcer and the treatment is IV injections of one of a number of highly poisonous medications, such as pentavalent antimony. The disease can also manifest with growths inside the nose and mouth which can be disfiguring and enlargement of the liver and spleen which can be life threatening if untreated.
My study is based at the Health Post of Corte de Pedra, a small village 300km southwest of Salvador, Bahia. For the past 30 years, farmers have been coming from as far as 60km away, by bus, car and on foot, to be treated (for free) at the rural clinic, which specializes exclusively in leishmania treatment. Glucantime (the drug) is provided to the patients for free, courtesy of the Brazilian government. The history of the clinic itself is interesting, as it was built by the residents’ committee of Corte de Pedra, which raised funds and constructed the building, with the help of a physician named Jackson Costa, after whom the health post was named. Monday through Friday, the clinic is staffed by a number of nurses (Renda, Nelsa and Flavia) and a Peruvian doctor named Julia. They attend to patients who arrive daily, but to be treated, patients must return to be seen by the team of dermatologists and the ear, nose and throat specialist who come from Salvador to see patients twice a month. There is also a house attached to the clinic where doctors and researchers can stay, and where I will be staying for short periods.
Over the past 30 years, doctors in the leishmania clinic have been noticing that the disease has been getting worse. In fact, the number of cases seen this July has been unprecedented, and researchers and physicians are at a loss to explain the troubling trend. Yesterday, the clinic ran out of medication in the middle of a clinic day, which means that patients had to return to their homes many miles away, with instructions to return another day, just to obtain the medication. The journey to and from the clinic can take many hours on difficult dirt roads and can very expensive, not to mention the hours of lost work it requires.
One of the problems with leishmaniasis is that little is known about it because it is a neglected disease. Funding for medical research comes in part from governments, but also largely from the pharmaceutical industry. Developing drugs costs millions of dollars. There is a huge incentive for drug companies to research diseases which affect the wealthy, in hopes of discovering a drug that people in wealthy countries will have to take for a lifetime (like cholesterol or blood pressure medications). However, diseases which affect the global poor, such as parasites, tuberculosis, rabies, malaria, and leishmaniasis, among many others, do not promise a future market of wealthy customers to offset the substantial costs of medical research. The reliance on the market to provide incentives for research on neglected diseases is a major reason why little is known about the mechanism of infection of leishmaniasis, and why there are few drugs available to treat it. Doctors have been noticing that in recent years the disease also seems to be affecting a broader population – it used to affect mostly males between the ages of 10 and 50, but now is affecting women, children, and the elderly more often, which may suggest that the insects which transmit the disease live closer to people’s homes, as opposed to out in the farms where men traditionally work. No one has sat down with the data to see if this is really happening. Enter: me. My research for the year will be a medical chart review, which means I basically get to sit down with a pile of medical records from 1982 until the present, putting age, gender, residence, occupation of patients into a database to see how the disease has changed over the past 30 years. My consolation prize for such tedious work (aside from the joy of helping people, blah, blah, blah): a year in tropical paradise.
With that said, come visit! Please, email me! Lara.jirmanus@gmail.com and please, do skype! Larazj is my screenname.
Beijos! Lara
One of the best parts of my time here so far has been dancing forro (pronounced fo-HO), which is native to the northeast of Brazil, and is danced with a partner to the swinging music of accordion, zabumba (a type of drum) and triangle. How those instruments create the most charming and cheerful music imaginable is a mystery, but I promise you they do. I think it was watching Rob, an American medical student living in the Cornell apartment with me, who is utterly enamored with forro, sway from side to side, with his hands in the air as though holding an imaginary partner, that helped me truly appreciate its charm. Those of you in Boston who do dance forro, I beg you to take him with you sometime. You will not regret it. :)
My Spanish has been slowly but surely converting into Portuguese, and the mishaps in the beginning, were if anything, a reason for me to walk around all day smiling at everyone’s good natured attempts to understand me. I think my favorite story being when I was looking for the mall, so I could get some passport photos taken and I stopped to have a conversation which translates as the following.
Me: Where is the evil? (ie. Onde esta o mall?)
Guy selling fruits: The what? (O que?)
Me: (Hmm…maybe the word isn’t mall) The building with many businesses inside. (O edifiço com muitos negocios la dentro)
Guy: Oh, the mall. (O…o shopping)
And that was how I learned that mall in Portuguese, or at least in Brazil is “shopping.” Well, you get to decide whether I misspoke.
My work has only just begun in earnest. I’ve been spending some days in various clinics at the Hospital das Clinicas, affiliated with UFBA, the Federal University of Bahia, seeing mostly patients with diseases that we don’t see much of in the US, like leprosy, rheumatic fever, HTLV-1 (which for those of you budding neurologists, I would suggest you come check out, because it’s really interesting). So, why am I here, except of course to train capoeira (more groups than you can count here in Bahia, where the martial art was born), and soak up the sun and music. I am here to study cutaneous leishmaniasis.
Leishmaniasis is not common in the city of Salvador, but is endemic to parts of the interior of Brazil, especially in the areas where rainforest has been cleared to create large plantations. If you dare to glance at my photos (I will label them carefully I promise, so you can avoid gross pictures if you wish) you will see the classic lesions. Basically, leishmaniasis is caused by
My study is based at the Health Post of Corte de Pedra, a small village 300km southwest of Salvador, Bahia. For the past 30 years, farmers have been coming from as far as 60km away, by bus, car and on foot, to be treated (for free) at the rural clinic, which specializes exclusively in leishmania treatment. Glucantime (the drug) is provided to the patients for free, courtesy of the Brazilian government. The history of the clinic itself is interesting, as it was built by the residents’ committee of Corte de Pedra, which raised funds and constructed the building, with the help of a physician named Jackson Costa, after whom the health post was named. Monday through Friday, the clinic is staffed by a number of nurses (Renda, Nelsa and Flavia) and a Peruvian doctor named Julia. They attend to patients who arrive daily, but to be treated, patients must return to be seen by the team of dermatologists and the ear, nose and throat specialist who come from Salvador to see patients twice a month. There is also a house attached to the clinic where doctors and researchers can stay, and where I will be staying for short periods.
Over the past 30 years, doctors in the leishmania clinic have been noticing that the disease has been getting worse. In fact, the number of cases seen this July has been unprecedented, and researchers and physicians are at a loss to explain the troubling trend. Yesterday, the clinic ran out of medication in the middle of a clinic day, which means that patients had to return to their homes many miles away, with instructions to return another day, just to obtain the medication. The journey to and from the clinic can take many hours on difficult dirt roads and can very expensive, not to mention the hours of lost work it requires.
One of the problems with leishmaniasis is that little is known about it because it is a neglected disease. Funding for medical research comes in part from governments, but also largely from the pharmaceutical industry. Developing drugs costs millions of dollars. There is a huge incentive for drug companies to research diseases which affect the wealthy, in hopes of discovering a drug that people in wealthy countries will have to take for a lifetime (like cholesterol or blood pressure medications). However, diseases which affect the global poor, such as parasites, tuberculosis, rabies, malaria, and leishmaniasis, among many others, do not promise a future market of wealthy customers to offset the substantial costs of medical research. The reliance on the market to provide incentives for research on neglected diseases is a major reason why little is known about the mechanism of infection of leishmaniasis, and why there are few drugs available to treat it. Doctors have been noticing that in recent years the disease also seems to be affecting a broader population – it used to affect mostly males between the ages of 10 and 50, but now is affecting women, children, and the elderly more often, which may suggest that the insects which transmit the disease live closer to people’s homes, as opposed to out in the farms where men traditionally work. No one has sat down with the data to see if this is really happening. Enter: me. My research for the year will be a medical chart review, which means I basically get to sit down with a pile of medical records from 1982 until the present, putting age, gender, residence, occupation of patients into a database to see how the disease has changed over the past 30 years. My consolation prize for such tedious work (aside from the joy of helping people, blah, blah, blah): a year in tropical paradise.
With that said, come visit! Please, email me! Lara.jirmanus@gmail.com and please, do skype! Larazj is my screenname.
Beijos! Lara
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)