Tuesday, September 04, 2012

How many Cuban doctors does a barrel of Venezuelan oil buy?


I am sure you are all wondering, as I was, how to bring a massive scale up of primary care with an army of Cuban doctors to a developing country near you, or, perhaps even to a “developed” country, such as the USA. Which of course, begs the question , who on earth is paying for all this? 

In order to understand where the funding comes from, we have to take a step back and look at the economic and political situation in Venezuela, in the first years of Hugo Chavez's presidency.  As you may recall, Hugo Chavez was elected in 1998, and his first few years in office were made difficult in part by economic challenges, low prices for Venezuelan oil on the world market, but also by political opposition of the big business leaders and representatives in the national legislature and the Supreme Court.  Knowing that his strength lay in popular support, Chavez convoked a constitutional assembly to rewrite the Venezuelan constitution.  Representatives were elected and the project was completed rapidly, and the new constitution was approved by a national vote in December 1999, thus creating the Venezuelan Fifth Republic, officially the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela.  The new constitution guarantees rights to housing, education, healthcare, food, indigenous lands, women’s rights, workers’ rights, among others. 

In 2001, Chavez used the new constitution to create a series of misiones sociales, or social missions, including the Mision Barrio Adentro, as well as land reform laws and laws regarding distribution of oil revenue. These laws set the Venezuelan oligarchy into a panic and they quickly took action to preserve their wealth, making repeated attempts to unseat Chavez, including economic disruptions, as well as, most memorably, the coup d’etat in 2002, during which Chavez was removed from power for little more than 24 hours.  In the following months, the big business confederation tried to cripple the economy by closing business and factories, and ultimately spurred the management strike that shut down the state-owned oil business, Petroleos de Venezuela, S.A. (PDVSA).  As nearly all oil exports halted, Chavez took action, firing the senior management of PDVSA and the employees who had cooperated with the shut down. He then consolidated control over oil revenues and began investing the profits directly in social projects, such as Mision Barrio Adentro.  

Mision Barrio Adentro is one of over 20 social missions enacted under the government of President Chavez.  They include educational initiatives, such as Mision Robinson, Ribas and Sucre which focus on adult literacy, secondary school education and higher education for adults. Through Mision Robinson, 1.5 million Venezuelans were taught to read and Venezuela was declared free of illiteracy in October 2005, as certified by the director of UNESCO.  Other initiatives focus on agriculture, food, employment, indigenous rights, environment, housing, science, and culture among others.  The investment in these social projects has been credited with the subsequent growth of the Venezuelan economy, as well as a significant decline in the poverty rate, which was cut in half from 62.1 percent in 2003 to 31.5 percent in 2008.  While Venezuela’s upper classes saw income gains of 194 percent from 1998 to 2006, the lower classes saw income gains of 445 percent.  

So, how many doctors does a barrel of Venezuelan oil buy, you may ask.  Ah, but it takes more than doctors to rebuild an economy, or even to deliver health care.   On October 30, 2000, the Cuba-Venezuela Comprehensive Cooperation Agreement was signed by Fidel Castro and Hugo Chavez, and Venezuela started providing 53,000 barrels of crude oil per day in exchange for goods and services that Cuba would offer "in support of the broad program of economic and social development of the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela."  Over the years, this commerce has expanded significantly. By 2009 the exchange was valued at over $3 billion annually. 

Cuban doctors are only a few among many professionals contributing to the economic development of Venezuela.  Cuban teachers, agronomists, technicians, engineers, among many other experts have helped Venezuela make great leaps in nearly 12 years of collaboration.  In the medical field  the contributions are astounding, as each group of consultorios is served by a diagnostic center, staffed by Cuban laboratory and radiology technicians, dentisits, optometrists, along with specialists such as ophthalmologists, surgeons, obstetricians, pediatricians, nurses, physical education instructors and rehabilitation specialists. Specifically, the government touts the successes of Operation Miracle, which began in July 2004, and has provided over 300,000 sight-preserving operations free-of-charge at centers staffed by Cuban ophthalmologists across the country. The plan for sustainability: training hundreds of Venezuelans doctors, in their very own barrios, to work alongside the Cuban physicians, of course. 

Not every country has the resources to be able to support such a significant commerce with Cuba, however, when a country is in need, Cuba is ready to send support and stick it out for the long term.  Perhaps no greater example of this exists in the world than the Cuban collaboration with Haiti, where they are also helping to build a primary health care system and training Haitian doctors, with the contribution of resources from the members of ALBA (the Bolivarian Alliance of the Americas whose member countries include Antigua and Barbuda, Bolivia, Cuba, Dominica, Ecuador, Nicaragua, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines and Venezuela). 

As for the Cuban professionals whose missions last between one and three years, as far as I can tell, their biggest complaint is the food. “Arepa, arepa, arepa. The only thing Venezuelans eat are arepas,” says Alicia, one of the Cuban nurses who lives and works at the Mision Niño Jesus, the home for pregnant women where I am being housed. “That’s why their cholesterol is so high.”  She is cooking con gris, the Cuban rice with black beans.  

Venezuelans eat rice and beans too, they just don’t mix them together.  It seems the Venezuelans have similar opinions about Cuban eating habits.  “Con gris, con gris,” says Maria Cassanova, the Director of the Town Government in Sanare. “I once went to Cuba, and all they eat is con gris, con gris, con gris with every meal.” 

The details of the proper way to eat rice and beans is beyond me…I’ll take either, and I enjoy the meals prepared by the staff at the mission, and in the evenings by the nurses who cook the food they prefer.  I even prepared them a meal of Lebanese food, chicken and rice, with spices given to me by the Palestinian shop owner down the street, who moved to Venezuela from Ramallah 50 years ago.  The security guard at the house jokes over lunch with Petra who runs the Mision Niño Jesus in Sanare, “The doctor cooked dinner last night, and it was wonderful.  It cured me.” Wilma, one of the Cuban nurses, nods her head in agreement.  “All those spices, I ate a big dish and I slept perfectly well last night. Si, era curativo.”

1 comment:

Matt said...

Enthralling. A great overview of the history and future. And funny, too. Fit to publish...