Sunday, December 21, 2008

My roommate Franklin said to me before leaving Salvador, “I went to a straight club with you, now it’s time for you to come to a gay club with me.” “Of course,” I said. “Whenever there’s music and dancing, you can count me in.”

It was surprisingly difficult to gather up a posse to go to Off Club, which is located in the tourist-fillled Barra neighborhood of Salvador. Everyone seems to have other plans. A couple of women in Franklin’s research group decline saying, they would feel “out of place”. A friend of mine says he’ll come along. “Wow, he’s a real kamikaze,” was Franklin’s reaction. “What do you mean?” I said. “You know those Japanese pilots…” “Yes, I am familiar with the term.” “Look,” says Franklin. “For a straight guy to go to a gay club in Brazil…he must be really hard hit for you is all I’m saying.” But my kamikaze calls to cancel around 10PM.

According to the Groupo Gay da Bahia (GGB), Brazil leads the world in the number of hate crimes committed against GLBT individuals, with an average of 100 people murdered annually. In Brazil, victims of homophobic violence tend to be young and of African descent (70%). The northeastern part of Brazil suffers from the highest rates of violence against gays, and during the year 2008, the state of Bahia stepped into the lead with 20 murders, followed by 19 murders in São Paulo. For the purposes of comparison, according to the FBI’s 2006 report on hate crimes, in 2006 in the United States, 1,415 sexual-orientation motivated hate crimes were committed, mostly assault, vandalism and intimidation. No murders or non-negligent manslaughters were recorded.

I found the statistic surprising when I first saw it…Brazil doesn’t stand out to me as a society which is particularly more homophobic than others which I have observed. Perhaps it is the difference in gender norms that threw me off, for example, in the United States a man dancing samba would not be considered particularly masculine. But I can’t help but feel like the society is more open when drag queens hand out flyers to straight clubs, or dance samba in the street dolled up in carnaval feathers and frill in the midst of crowds clapping and cheering, “Opa!” Or even while watching participants in a ceremony of candomblé, the religion which originated among African slaves in the state of Bahia and has been practiced for four centuries, it is difficult to avoid noting that the effeminate aspect of some of the male participants. Not to mention some of the really positive news coverage of the marital ceremony uniting two men which was held this week in a terreiro de candomblé in Lauro de Freitas, Bahia, about 30 miles from Salvador. (No, the marriage will not be recognized by the Brazilian government.)

In my albeit brief internet search I had trouble confirming the comparative data that would place Brazil ahead of all other nations in sexual-orientation motivated hate crimes; it is furthermore important to consider that many countries (and indeed many states in the US) do not collect statistics on hate crimes motivated by sexual orientation. Regardless, perhaps the word kamikaze was more appropriate than I appreciated.

We arrive at about 12:15AM…getting a ride from one of my roommate’s colleagues Ridalva and her husband, Mauricio. The club is predictably deserted when we walk in—come on, who comes to a club before at least 1AM—and ice cold, the air conditioning cranked up in anticipation of the 300 people who would soon be bouncing to electronic music within its black walls. We get a drink and settle in on an uncomfortable couch on the club’s second floor.
The entire space inside the club is designed to force people to look outward. A few couches only big enough for two. A single row of stools against the wall with tables in front of them. You can’t sit opposite anyone, or with your back to anyone. A balcony to look down at people on the dance floor below. We stand up to watch people arrive as I comment to my roommate. “You know, I feel like I’m doing an comparative study here. I’ve already been to gay clubs in 3 countries (US, Lebanon, Colombia). This would be my fourth.”

As the people slowly trickle in, I begin to make my profound observations. Clubgoers wearing shorts. That would break dress code in most clubs I’ve been to. And then perhaps an interesting finding, there are very few black men (though perhaps more than I’ve seen black residents and med students in the hospital and clinics I’ve worked in here). My friends don’t seem too surprised. “Not everyone has R$20 (about 10USD) for cover,” they say. More on this another day, but let us note once again where the legacy of slavery rears its ugly head.

There are also very, very few women, perhaps 15 to 20 in the entire club. I’ve never seen so few in a gay club, but there’s no discount for women. My friends Claudia and Roberta confirm that in Brazil, consistent at least with the US and Lebanon (correct me if I’m wrong folks), so-called “gay” clubs are not often a space for queer women. They complain that there aren’t many spaces for queer women to hang out in Salvador, but Claudia the positive side of this. “I think in Brazil we’re less ghettoized than in other places. We’re more integrated into society.” Roberta disagrees. “That’s not the way it is in São Paulo,” where Roberta is from. “There are neighborhoods where gay people live and where there are queer-friendly bars. Salvador is just a smaller city.” But that said, she continues to talk about how open she is about her personal life. “I just act like it’s normal and then it is. When I interviewed for my job here and they asked me if I was married, I said ‘Yes, I’ve been married to Claudia for 6 years,’ and people accept it. Now everyone knows.” If Salvador is so queer friendly, then where are these hate crimes happening, I wonder. Some of my friends conjecture that life in the favelas is more difficult for queer folks. Off Club is certainly in a posh neighborhood.

At 1:26AM the first shirts start to come off. “What?” I say. “OK. I haven’t seen that in a gay club before…at least not among the clubgoers.” “Oh yeah,” Franklin confirms. “See that group of guys there? I guarantee you in a few minutes they’ll be shirtless too. There’s always a group of hot guys that hang out together, and then they all take their shirts off.” Amazing…score one point Brazil.

Every few minutes Mauricio seems to run into someone else he knows, and we start joking about his secret nightlife. He laughs nervously, his arm around his wife’s waist. “Don’t feel bad if the guys here aren’t paying attention to you,” he says. “It’s not you.” But then, Franklin smiles at me, “I think you have an admirer,” he says. Now that he mentions it, that girl does sort of seem to be following me around the dance floor. Hmm…she’s pretty cute. “Aproveite!” says Ridalva. I laugh, and kinda start blushing. What do I do? Look at her? Not look at her? By the time I gather myself together, she’s already disappeared.

We go back upstairs to watch the crowd from below. As predicted the group of hot guys have tucked their shirts into their back pockets and are standing by the wall, looking bored and beautiful.

At around 4am we walk out of the club, our ears ringing from the thumping techno music. “So what did you think?” said Franklin. I give my grand cross-cultural impression: “Not so different from most clubs I've been too. I just hope everyone gets home safely.”